Petrovskaya Olga
School of Nursing, University of Victoria, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada.
Nurs Philos. 2023 Jun 15:e12448. doi: 10.1111/nup.12448.
In this paper, I argue that critical posthumanism is a crucial tool in nursing philosophy and scholarship. Posthumanism entails a reconsideration of what 'human' is and a rejection of the whole tradition founding Western life in the 2500 years of our civilization as narrated in founding texts and embodied in governments, economic formations and everyday life. Through an overview of historical periods, texts and philosophy movements, I problematize humanism, showing how it centres white, heterosexual, able-bodied Man at the top of a hierarchy of beings, and runs counter to many current aspirations in nursing and other disciplines: decolonization, antiracism, anti-sexism and Indigenous resurgence. In nursing, the term humanism is often used colloquially to mean kind and humane; yet philosophically, humanism denotes a Western philosophical tradition whose tenets underpin much of nursing scholarship. These underpinnings of Western humanism have increasingly become problematic, especially since the 1960s motivating nurse scholars to engage with antihumanist and, recently, posthumanist theory. However, even current antihumanist nursing arguments manifest deep embeddedness in humanistic methodologies. I show both the problematic underside of humanism and critical posthumanism's usefulness as a tool to fight injustice and examine the materiality of nursing practice. In doing so, I hope to persuade readers not to be afraid of understanding and employing this critical tool in nursing research and scholarship.
在本文中,我认为批判性后人类主义是护理哲学和学术研究中的一个关键工具。后人类主义需要重新思考“人类”是什么,并摒弃在我们2500年文明中奠定西方生活基础的整个传统,这些传统在奠基性文本中有叙述,并体现在政府、经济形态和日常生活中。通过对历史时期、文本和哲学运动的概述,我对人文主义提出质疑,展示了它如何将白人、异性恋、身体健全的男性置于存在等级制度的顶端,并且与护理及其他学科当前的许多愿望背道而驰:去殖民化、反种族主义、反性别歧视和本土复兴。在护理领域,人文主义一词通常通俗地用来表示善良和人道;然而从哲学角度来看,人文主义指的是一种西方哲学传统,其信条构成了许多护理学术研究的基础。西方人文主义的这些基础越来越成问题,尤其是自20世纪60年代以来,这促使护理学者去接触反人文主义理论,以及最近的后人类主义理论。然而,即使是当前反人文主义的护理观点也深深植根于人文主义方法论之中。我既展示了人文主义有问题的一面,也展示了批判性后人类主义作为一种与不公正作斗争以及审视护理实践物质性的工具的有用性。在此过程中,我希望说服读者不要害怕在护理研究和学术中理解和运用这一关键工具。