Postgraduate Program in Collective Health, State University of Ceará, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil.
Department of Education, Federal University of Paraná, Curitiba, Paraná, Brazil.
J Sch Health. 2023 Nov;93(11):1036-1044. doi: 10.1111/josh.13349. Epub 2023 Jun 19.
Bystanders' role in bullying situations is important, and may exacerbate or minimize the problem. Thus, this article aims to identify the characteristics of anti-bullying programs with an emphasis on bystanders.
This is a scoping review. We included studies that addressed interventions with an emphasis on bystanders, carried out with school children and adolescents, aimed at reducing bullying/cyberbullying and/or increasing defending behavior. Fifteen portals/databases were searched. The selection and extraction processes were carried out through the blind review strategy. The synthesis took place descriptively.
We found 12 interventions. The most investigated were KiVa (n = 9), STAC (n = 3), and Curriculum-Based Anti-Bullying (n = 2).
There are few anti-bullying programs with an emphasis on bystanders, and the majority are universal programs with strategies applied by teachers, giving little attention to parents. Moreover, most of these programs lack a broader mix of anti-bullying strategies. Therefore, we suggest developing anti-bullying programs with multiple components that contain universal, selective, and indicated strategies.
旁观者在欺凌事件中的角色很重要,他们可能会加剧或减轻问题。因此,本文旨在确定以旁观者为重点的反欺凌计划的特征。
这是一项范围界定审查。我们纳入了强调旁观者的干预措施的研究,这些研究针对的是在校儿童和青少年,旨在减少欺凌/网络欺凌和/或增加防御行为。搜索了 15 个门户/数据库。选择和提取过程通过盲审策略进行。综合采用描述性方法进行。
我们发现了 12 项干预措施。研究最多的是 KiVa(n=9)、STAC(n=3)和基于课程的反欺凌(n=2)。
以旁观者为重点的反欺凌计划很少,大多数是针对教师的通用计划,很少关注家长。此外,这些计划大多缺乏更广泛的反欺凌策略组合。因此,我们建议开发具有多种组成部分的反欺凌计划,其中包含通用、选择性和针对性策略。