Clifton Rachel, Bamford Kate, Green Laura
School of Life Sciences, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom.
Front Vet Sci. 2023 Jun 9;10:1171853. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2023.1171853. eCollection 2023.
Great Britain has over 15 million ewes. Lameness is one of the top three most economically important diseases for the sheep industry, costing about £80 million per annum. The prevalence of lameness reduced from 10% to 5% between 2004 and 2013 but further reduction is unlikely because many farmers and agricultural students still believe in, and use, ineffective practices to control lameness. Unfortunately, many veterinary practitioners consider themselves insufficiently knowledgeable to work confidently with sheep farmers, and many sheep farmers agree with them. Another route to improve control of lameness is to ensure that all new veterinary graduates are competent to advise farmers.
Our study investigated how veterinary students are taught about management of lameness in sheep. Ten lecturers from eight veterinary schools were interviewed, and 33 students from four veterinary schools participated in four focus groups; all were recorded, transcribed, and analysed using directed qualitative content analysis.
Teaching time and opportunities for students to gain clinical experience of lameness were very limited. Students were not confident they could diagnose causes of lameness and listed many practices, including ineffective ones, to manage footrot.
We conclude that GB veterinary students are graduating without evidence-based understanding and clinical experience necessary to advise farmers on management of lameness in sheep. Given the importance of lameness in sheep in GB we conclude that an alternative approach to education on lameness in sheep could help to ensure that new graduate veterinarians can contribute to control of lameness in sheep.
英国有超过1500万只母羊。跛足是养羊业中经济影响最为重大的三大疾病之一,每年造成的损失约为8000万英镑。2004年至2013年间,跛足的患病率从10%降至5%,但进一步降低的可能性不大,因为许多农民和农业专业学生仍然相信并采用无效的方法来控制跛足。不幸的是,许多兽医从业者认为自己在与养羊农民合作时知识不足,许多养羊农民也认同这一点。另一条改善跛足控制的途径是确保所有新毕业的兽医都有能力为农民提供建议。
我们的研究调查了兽医专业学生是如何接受关于羊跛足管理的教学的。对来自八所兽医学院的十位讲师进行了访谈,来自四所兽医学院的33名学生参加了四个焦点小组;所有内容都进行了录音、转录,并使用定向定性内容分析法进行了分析。
学生获得跛足临床经验的教学时间和机会非常有限。学生们对自己能否诊断跛足病因缺乏信心,并列出了许多管理腐蹄病的方法,包括无效的方法。
我们得出结论,英国兽医专业学生毕业时缺乏为农民提供羊跛足管理建议所需的循证理解和临床经验。鉴于跛足对英国养羊业的重要性,我们得出结论,一种关于羊跛足教育的替代方法有助于确保新毕业的兽医能够为控制羊跛足做出贡献。