Teggi Roberto, Colombo Bruno, Cangiano Iacopo, Gatti Omar, Bussi Mario, Filippi Massimo
Department of Otolaryngology, IRCCS San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Via Olgettina 60, 20132 Milan, Italy.
Neurology Unit, IRCCS San Raffaele Scientific Institute, 20132 Milan, Italy.
Audiol Res. 2023 Jun 8;13(3):466-472. doi: 10.3390/audiolres13030041.
Menière's disease and vestibular migraine (VM) are two common inner ear disorders whose diagnoses are based on clinical history and audiometric exams. In some cases, patients have been reporting different episodes of vertigo for years but not fulfilling the Bárány Society criteria for either. These are called Recurrent Vestibular Symptoms-Not Otherwise Specified (RVS-NOS). It is still under debate if this is a single disease entity or a part of the spectrum of already established disorders. The purpose of our work was to establish similarities and differences with VM in terms of clinical history, bedside examination, and family history. We enrolled 28 patients with RVS-NOS who were followed for at least 3 years with stable diagnosis; results were compared with those of 34 subjects having a diagnosis of definite VM. The age of onset of vertigo was lower in VM than in RVS-NOS (31.2 vs. 38.4 years). As for the duration of attacks and symptoms, we detected no differences other than subjects with RVS-NOS reporting milder attacks. Cochlear accompanying symptoms were more frequently reported by VM subjects (one subject reporting tinnitus and another one reported tinnitus and fullness). Motion sickness was equally reported by subjects across two samples (around 50% for both). Bipositional long-lasting, non-paroxysmal nystagmus was the most common finding in the two groups, with no significant difference. Finally, the percentage of familial cases of migrainous headache and episodic vertigo did not differ between the two samples. In conclusion, RVS-NOS shares some common aspects with VM, including the temporal profile of attacks, motion sickness (commonly considered a migraine precursor), bedside examination, and family history. Our results are not inconsistent with the possibility that RVS-NOS may be a heterogeneous disorder, even if some of these subjects may share common pathophysiological mechanisms with VM.
梅尼埃病和前庭性偏头痛(VM)是两种常见的内耳疾病,其诊断基于临床病史和听力检查。在某些情况下,患者多年来一直报告有不同发作的眩晕,但不符合巴兰尼协会对这两种疾病的诊断标准。这些被称为未另作说明的复发性前庭症状(RVS-NOS)。这是一种单一疾病实体还是已确定疾病谱的一部分仍存在争议。我们研究的目的是在临床病史、床边检查和家族史方面确定RVS-NOS与VM的异同。我们纳入了28例RVS-NOS患者,他们被随访至少3年且诊断稳定;结果与34例确诊为VM的受试者进行比较。VM患者眩晕的发病年龄低于RVS-NOS患者(31.2岁对38.4岁)。至于发作和症状的持续时间,除了RVS-NOS患者报告发作较轻外,我们未发现其他差异。VM患者更常报告有耳蜗伴随症状(一名患者报告耳鸣,另一名患者报告耳鸣和耳闷)。两个样本中的受试者晕动病报告率相同(均约为50%)。双侧位持续、非阵发性眼球震颤是两组中最常见的表现,无显著差异。最后,两组中偏头痛性头痛和发作性眩晕的家族病例百分比没有差异。总之,RVS-NOS与VM有一些共同之处,包括发作的时间特征、晕动病(通常被认为是偏头痛先兆)、床边检查和家族史。我们的结果与RVS-NOS可能是一种异质性疾病的可能性并不矛盾,即使其中一些受试者可能与VM有共同的病理生理机制。