Jacobi Davina, Ide Tobias
Discipline Area of Nursing, IUBH International University, 53604 Bad Honnef, Germany.
Center of Biosecurity and OneHealth, Murdoch University, Murdoch, WA 6150, Australia.
Nurs Rep. 2023 Jun 14;13(2):902-912. doi: 10.3390/nursrep13020079.
Concerns about violence against nurses and other medical personnel have increased during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, as of yet, limited systematic knowledge of such violence is available. Addressing this gap, we analyse the geographical distribution of, motivations behind, and contexts of collective attacks against health workers in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. To do so, we systematically recorded and coded attack events worldwide from 1 March 2020 to 31 December 2021. We identify high-risk countries, attack characteristics, and the socio-economic contexts in which attacks tend to occur. Our results show that opposition against public health measures (28.5%), fears of infection (22.3%), and supposed lack of care (20.6%) were the most common reasons for attacks. Most attacks occurred in facilities (often related to a supposed lack of care) or while health workers were on duty in a public place (often due to opposition to public health measures). However, 17.9% of all attacks took place in off-duty settings. Democratic countries with high vaccination rates and strong health systems were relatively safe for nurses and doctors. Distrust in the skills of health workers and the science underlying health interventions is a major driver of collective attack risks and should be addressed before it turns violent. This study was not registered.
在新冠疫情期间,针对护士和其他医务人员的暴力行为引发了更多关注。然而,截至目前,关于此类暴力行为的系统性知识仍然有限。为填补这一空白,我们分析了新冠疫情背景下针对医护人员的集体袭击事件的地理分布、背后动机及相关背景。为此,我们系统记录并编码了2020年3月1日至2021年12月31日期间全球范围内的袭击事件。我们确定了高风险国家、袭击特征以及袭击往往发生的社会经济背景。我们的研究结果表明,反对公共卫生措施(28.5%)、对感染的恐惧(22.3%)以及所谓的护理缺失(20.6%)是袭击的最常见原因。大多数袭击发生在医疗机构(通常与所谓的护理缺失有关)或医护人员在公共场所值班期间(通常是由于反对公共卫生措施)。然而,所有袭击事件中有17.9%发生在非工作场所。疫苗接种率高且卫生系统强大的民主国家对护士和医生来说相对安全。对医护人员技能以及健康干预背后科学的不信任是集体袭击风险的主要驱动因素,在其演变为暴力行为之前应加以解决。本研究未进行注册。