Jacobi Davina, Ide Tobias
Discipline Area of Nursing, IUBH International University, 99084 Erfurt, Germany.
Center of Biosecurity and One Health, Murdoch University, Murdoch, WA 6150, Australia.
Nurs Rep. 2024 Aug 9;14(3):1961-1972. doi: 10.3390/nursrep14030146.
Nurses play key roles in dealing with pandemics yet are often conceived solely as "technical" experts without political agency. This study conducts the first global comparative analysis of COVID-19-related protests of nurses and other frontline health workers, with a focus on the first 18 months of the pandemic. We draw on quantitative and qualitative data on nurses' protests and protest drivers. Results show that such protests were widespread: We identify 3515 events in 90 countries, with several regional hotspots existing. The most common reasons for protests were poor working conditions and insufficient workplace safety, followed by wider social issues like poverty and racism. For most of the time period under consideration, protests demanding access to vaccinations (a rarely explored phenomenon) were more widespread than anti-vaccination events. Protest frequency was highest in countries with high COVID-19-related mortality rates, high levels of human development, and strong social movements at the onset of the pandemic. Recognising the key role of nurses as political actors would help to improve health policies and to maintain a capable healthcare workforce, particularly during acute crises like pandemics.
护士在应对大流行中发挥着关键作用,但往往仅被视为没有政治影响力的“技术”专家。本研究首次对护士及其他一线医护人员与新冠疫情相关的抗议活动进行了全球比较分析,重点关注疫情的头18个月。我们利用了关于护士抗议活动及抗议驱动因素的定量和定性数据。结果表明,此类抗议活动很普遍:我们在90个国家识别出3515起事件,存在几个区域热点。抗议的最常见原因是工作条件差和工作场所安全不足,其次是贫困和种族主义等更广泛的社会问题。在所考虑的大部分时间段内,要求获得疫苗接种的抗议活动(一种很少被探讨的现象)比反疫苗接种事件更为普遍。抗议频率在新冠疫情相关死亡率高、人类发展水平高且在疫情初期有强大社会运动的国家最高。认识到护士作为政治行为者的关键作用将有助于改善卫生政策,并维持一支有能力的医疗劳动力队伍,特别是在像大流行这样的急性危机期间。