Israel-Turim Verónica, Laferrara Valentina, Rego Ana Regina, Micó-Sanz Josep Lluís
Blanquerna School of Communications and International Relations, Ramon Llull University, 08022 Barcelona, Spain.
Rede Nacional de Combate à Desinformação RNCd, Rio de Janeiro 21941-853, Brazil.
Vaccines (Basel). 2023 Jun 1;11(6):1054. doi: 10.3390/vaccines11061054.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, online media were the most widely used sources of scientific information. Often, they are also the only ones on science-related topics. Research has shown that much of the information available on the Internet about the health crisis lacked scientific rigor, and that misinformation about health issues can pose a threat to public health. In turn, millions of Catholics were found to be demonstrating against vaccination against COVID-19 based on "false" and misleading religious arguments. This research analyses publications about the vaccine in Catholic online media with the aim of understanding the presence of information (and misinformation) in this community. An algorithm designed for each media outlet collected COVID-19 vaccine-related publications from 109 Catholic media outlets in five languages. In total, 970 publications were analysed for journalistic genres, types of headlines and sources of information. The results show that most publications are informative and most of their headlines are neutral. However, opinion articles have mostly negative headlines. Furthermore, a higher percentage of the opinion authors come from the religious sphere and most of the sources cited are religious. Finally, 35% of the publications relate the vaccine to the framing issue of abortion.
在新冠疫情期间,网络媒体是使用最广泛的科学信息来源。通常,它们也是唯一涉及科学相关话题的媒体。研究表明,互联网上有关健康危机的许多信息缺乏科学严谨性,而且关于健康问题的错误信息会对公众健康构成威胁。反过来,数以百万计的天主教徒被发现基于“虚假”且具有误导性的宗教观点反对新冠疫苗接种。本研究分析天主教网络媒体上有关疫苗的出版物,旨在了解该群体中信息(及错误信息)的存在情况。为每个媒体机构设计的一种算法从109家使用五种语言的天主教媒体机构收集了与新冠疫苗相关的出版物。总共对970篇出版物的新闻体裁、标题类型和信息来源进行了分析。结果显示,大多数出版物具有信息性,且其大多数标题是中性的。然而,评论文章大多具有负面标题。此外,评论文章的作者中有更高比例来自宗教领域,且所引用的大多数来源都是宗教性的。最后,35%的出版物将疫苗与堕胎的框架问题联系起来。