D'Alecy L G, Lundy E F, Barton K J, Zelenock G B
Surgery. 1986 Sep;100(3):505-11.
Use of dextrose in intravenous resuscitation fluids is common practice; however, this study indicates that 5% dextrose solutions, even if administered in physiologic quantities, greatly worsens the outcome of survivable cardiac arrest. Twelve adult male mongrel dogs were premedicated with morphine, anesthetized with halothane, instrumented, intubated, and ventilated. Each dog was first given 500 ml of either lactated Ringer's (LR) (n = 6) or 5% dextrose in LR (D5LR) (n = 6). Halothane was stopped and fibrillation was induced (60 Hz). Blood glucose just before cardiac arrest was 129 mg/dl in the LR dogs and was increased to 335 mg/dl in the D5LR dogs. After eight minutes of arrest, resuscitation, including internal cardiac massage and standard advanced cardiac life support drug protocols (modified for dogs), was begun. When stable cardiac rhythm was obtained, the chest was closed, and LR or D5LR continued until a total of 1L was given. A neurologic score (0 = normal to 100 = dead) was assigned at 1, 2, 6, and 24 hours. The LR group did not differ statistically from the D5LR group in operative time, number of defibrillatory shocks, time to spontaneous ventilation, time to extubation, or drugs required. Resuscitation was successful in all six LR and five of six D5LR group; however, by 2 hours after resuscitation and thereafter, D5LR group had a significantly greater neurologic deficit (p less than 0.05) than did the LR group. By 9 hours, four of six D5LR dogs displayed convulsive activity and died. At 24 hours the D5LR group had a greater (p less than 0.008) neurologic deficit (82 +/- 11) than did the LR group (21 +/- 7), which walked and ate. We conclude that the addition of 5% dextrose to standard intravenous fluids greatly increases the morbidity and mortality associated with cardiac resuscitation.
在静脉复苏液中使用葡萄糖是常见的做法;然而,这项研究表明,5%的葡萄糖溶液,即使以生理剂量给药,也会大大恶化可存活心脏骤停的预后。12只成年雄性杂种犬先用吗啡进行预处理,再用氟烷麻醉,然后进行仪器植入、插管和通气。每只犬首先给予500毫升乳酸林格氏液(LR)(n = 6)或含5%葡萄糖的乳酸林格氏液(D5LR)(n = 6)。停止使用氟烷并诱发心室颤动(60赫兹)。心脏骤停前,LR组犬的血糖为129毫克/分升,D5LR组犬的血糖升高至335毫克/分升。心脏骤停8分钟后,开始进行复苏,包括心脏内按摩和标准的高级心脏生命支持药物方案(针对犬进行了修改)。当获得稳定的心律后,关闭胸腔,并继续输注LR或D5LR,直至总量达到1升。在1小时、2小时、6小时和24小时时进行神经学评分(0 = 正常至100 = 死亡)。LR组和D5LR组在手术时间、除颤次数、自主通气时间、拔管时间或所需药物方面无统计学差异。所有6只LR组犬和6只D5LR组犬中的5只复苏成功;然而,复苏后2小时及之后,D5LR组的神经功能缺损明显大于LR组(p < 0.05)。到9小时时,6只D5LR犬中有4只出现惊厥活动并死亡。在24小时时,D5LR组的神经功能缺损(82±11)大于LR组(21±7),LR组的犬能够行走和进食。我们得出结论,在标准静脉输液中添加5%的葡萄糖会大大增加与心脏复苏相关的发病率和死亡率。