School of Dentistry, Department of Biomedical Technologies, University of Siena, Siena, Italy.
Eastman Institute of Oral Health, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York, USA.
J Oral Rehabil. 2023 Nov;50(11):1355-1361. doi: 10.1111/joor.13553. Epub 2023 Jul 11.
Few terms and concepts have been so extensively debated in dentistry as the words 'centric relation' (CR). Debates involve its biological, diagnostic and therapeutic usefulness.
A review of the literature on the current concepts on CR as a diagnostic or therapeutic aid in dentistry was provided. Clinical trials assessing the superiority of one CR recording method over the others to identify patients with temporomandibular disorders (diagnostic use) or to manage patients with prosthodontic or orthodontic needs (therapeutic use) were tentatively included.
Due to the absence of literature addressing either of the above targets, a comprehensive overview was provided. The diagnostic use of CR as a reference position to identify the correct position of the temporomandibular joint condyle within the glenoid fossa is not supported and lacks anatomical support. From a therapeutic standpoint, the use of CR can be pragmatically useful in prosthodontics as a maxillo-mandibular reference position when occlusal re-organization is warranted and/or when the position of maximum intercuspation is no longer available.
The derived occlusal goals from a diagnostic misuse of CR are generally the result of circular reasoning, that is a technique is based on the recording of a certain condylar position that is believed to be 'ideal' and the treatment is considered successful when such position is shown by the specific instrument that was manufactured for that purpose. The term 'Centric Relation' might be replaced with the term 'Maxillo-Mandibular Utility Position'.
在牙科领域,很少有术语和概念像“正中关系(centric relation,CR)”这样被广泛争论。这些争论涉及到其生物学、诊断和治疗的有用性。
本文对当前关于 CR 的概念进行了文献回顾,这些概念将 CR 作为诊断或治疗牙科的辅助手段。评估了一些临床试验,这些试验旨在评估一种 CR 记录方法相对于其他方法在识别颞下颌关节紊乱患者(诊断用途)或管理有修复或正畸需求的患者(治疗用途)方面的优越性。
由于缺乏针对上述任何一个目标的文献,因此提供了全面的概述。将 CR 用作参考位置来确定颞下颌关节髁突在关节窝内的正确位置的诊断用途不被支持,也缺乏解剖学支持。从治疗的角度来看,CR 在修复学中可以作为一种上颌下颌参考位置,在需要重新建立咬合关系和/或最大咬合位置不再可用时,可以使用 CR。
从对 CR 的诊断性误用中得出的咬合目标通常是循环推理的结果,即一种技术基于记录被认为是“理想”的特定髁突位置,并且当特定为此目的制造的仪器显示出这种位置时,治疗被认为是成功的。“正中关系”一词可能会被“上颌下颌实用位置”所取代。