Gok Haydar, Celik Suat Erol, Yangi Kivanc, Yavuz Ahmed Yasin, Percinoglu Gokhan, Unlu Nazmi Ugur, Goksu Kamber
Department of Neurosurgery, Turkish Republic Ministry of Health, University of Health Sciences, Prof.Dr.Cemil Tascioglu City Hospital, Sisli, Istanbul, Turkey.
Department of Neurosurgery, Turkish Republic Ministry of Health, University of Health Sciences, Prof.Dr.Cemil Tascioglu City Hospital, Sisli, Istanbul, Turkey.
World Neurosurg. 2023 Sep;177:e686-e692. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2023.06.123. Epub 2023 Jul 3.
We retrospectively reviewed and evaluated our treatment protocols in epidural hematoma (EDH) cases to compare surgical versus nonsurgical treatment subsections with their trauma mechanism, injury type, clinical pattern, radiological details, functional outcome, and mortality rates.
This study included 350 patients (142 females and 208 males) treated for EDH between 2010 and 2018. Two hundred seven operated and 143 observed patients for EDH were compared for demography, injury type, treatment, and outcome scores retrospectively. Glasgow Coma Scale and Glasgow Outcome Scale were used to standardize the clinical findings. Marshall and Rotterdam classifications classified radiological abnormalities. The Infinity PACS system measured hematoma volume, and volume parameters were evaluated differently in pediatric and adult groups.
Radiological parameters showed that the observation was more favorable when the EDH volume was <30 ml in the adult and <20 ml in the pediatric group. However, close clinical follow-up with repeated computerized tomography scans suggested that when the hematoma increases in volume in the first 24 hours, it should be treated surgically. Headache, vomiting, and paresis were significant clinical symptoms in this period. Only 11% of conservatively followed cases required delayed surgical intervention. When we analyzed the findings of the 2 groups of the patient, pediatric and adult, we noticed that rebleeding after the first surgery was more common in the adult group than the pediatric group, whereas surgery due to a growing hematoma was less common in the pediatric group.
Age, trauma severity, initial neurological statuses, and accompanying comorbidities can affect the functional outcome in acute EDH. We found that urgent surgical intervention and conservative treatment may lead to excellent results in most cases. Thus, EDH can be managed both conservatively and surgically in certain conditions. We made a comparison between pediatric and adult age groups according to treatment modalities. Both rebleeding and mortality rates are relatively lower in the pediatric operated group than in the adult operated group. In the adult observation group, rates of delayed surgery because of growing hematoma seem relatively higher than in the pediatric observation group. During radiological follow-up, we found that the progression rate of EDH in the adult observed group according to time is faster than in the pediatric observed group (P < 0.05).
我们回顾性地审查和评估了我们在硬膜外血肿(EDH)病例中的治疗方案,以比较手术治疗与非手术治疗亚组在创伤机制、损伤类型、临床模式、放射学细节、功能结局和死亡率方面的差异。
本研究纳入了2010年至2018年间接受EDH治疗的350例患者(142例女性和208例男性)。对207例接受手术治疗的EDH患者和143例接受观察的患者的人口统计学、损伤类型、治疗方法和结局评分进行了回顾性比较。采用格拉斯哥昏迷量表和格拉斯哥结局量表对临床结果进行标准化。采用马歇尔和鹿特丹分类法对放射学异常进行分类。使用Infinity PACS系统测量血肿体积,并且在儿童组和成人组中对体积参数进行了不同的评估。
放射学参数显示,当成人EDH体积<30 ml且儿童组<20 ml时,观察治疗更为有利。然而,通过重复计算机断层扫描进行密切的临床随访表明,当血肿在最初24小时内体积增加时,应进行手术治疗。在此期间,头痛、呕吐和轻瘫是显著的临床症状。在保守治疗的病例中,只有11%的患者需要延迟手术干预。当我们分析成人和儿童两组患者的结果时,我们注意到首次手术后再出血在成人组中比儿童组更常见,而因血肿增大而进行手术在儿童组中较少见。
年龄、创伤严重程度、初始神经状态和伴随的合并症可影响急性EDH的功能结局。我们发现,在大多数情况下,紧急手术干预和保守治疗可能会取得良好的效果。因此,在某些情况下,EDH既可以采用保守治疗也可以采用手术治疗。我们根据治疗方式对儿童和成人年龄组进行了比较。儿童手术组的再出血率和死亡率均相对低于成人手术组。在成人观察组中,因血肿增大而延迟手术的发生率似乎高于儿童观察组。在放射学随访期间,我们发现成人观察组中EDH随时间的进展速度比儿童观察组快(P < 0.05)。