Kinsley Sarah E, Song Shuang, Losina Elena, Talbot Simon G
Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
Hand (N Y). 2025 Jan;20(1):116-121. doi: 10.1177/15589447231184895. Epub 2023 Jul 6.
Candidate selection for upper extremity transplantation remains an inherently subjective process. This work evaluated the effect that psychosocial factors have on outcomes, both to standardize evaluation of potential candidates and in optimizing these factors prior to transplantation. Our goal was to measure and quantify the risk that various psychosocial factors have on transplant outcomes.
Given that we do not have sufficient post-transplant patients to examine specific factors, we chose to have experts in the field evaluate hypothetical patients based on their experience. We used a Generalized Estimating Equation to estimate and compare surgical candidacy scores using patient scenario vignettes based on the presence or absence of permutations of the following: (1) depression; (2) participation in occupational therapy (OT); (3) expectation of post-transplant function; (4) punctuality; and (5) family support were given to experts in the field.
This work suggests there is a decrease in predicted success with increasing numbers of negative factors with participation in OT and realistic expectations of outcomes being most important. An increase in the summarizing risk score from 0 to 1.7 was associated with a decrease in the outcome surgical candidacy score from 8.6 to 5.3, meaning candidates with 2 risk factors would often observe a large drop in surgical candidacy score.
Focusing on optimizing psychosocial variables in transplant candidates may help improve hand transplant success.
上肢移植的候选者选择仍然是一个本质上主观的过程。这项工作评估了心理社会因素对结果的影响,目的是使潜在候选者的评估标准化,并在移植前优化这些因素。我们的目标是测量和量化各种心理社会因素对移植结果的风险。
鉴于我们没有足够的移植后患者来研究特定因素,我们选择让该领域的专家根据他们的经验评估假设的患者。我们使用广义估计方程,根据以下因素的有无,通过患者情景 vignettes 来估计和比较手术候选分数:(1) 抑郁;(2) 参与职业治疗 (OT);(3) 移植后功能期望;(4) 守时;以及 (5) 家庭支持,并将这些提供给该领域的专家。
这项工作表明,随着负面因素数量的增加,预测成功率会下降,其中参与 OT 和对结果的现实期望最为重要。汇总风险评分从 0 增加到 1.7 与手术候选分数从 8.6 下降到 5.3 相关,这意味着有 2 个风险因素的候选者手术候选分数通常会大幅下降。
专注于优化移植候选者的心理社会变量可能有助于提高手部移植的成功率。