Wettstein Alexander, Jenni Gabriel, Schneider Sandra, Kühne Fabienne, Grosse Holtforth Martin, La Marca Roberto
Department of Research and Development, University of Teacher Education Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, Department of Psychology, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Soc Psychol Educ. 2023;26(4):1181-1200. doi: 10.1007/s11218-023-09782-2. Epub 2023 Apr 6.
Aggressive student behavior is considered a leading risk factor for teacher stress. However, teachers' coping styles may affect how they perceive and respond to aggressive student behavior. This study tests whether teachers' perceptions of aggressive student behavior mainly mirror objectively observed aggression in presence of the teacher (as coded by external observers) or whether teachers' perception of aggressive student behavior primarily reflects teachers' avoidant coping styles, such as chronic worry and resignation. Finally, we examine whether observed and teacher-perceived aggression relates to increased vital exhaustion and psychophysiological stress among teachers (i.e., higher hair cortisol concentration). In an ambulatory assessment study, we administered self-reports to 42 Swiss teachers to assess perceived student aggression, chronic worry, resignation, and vital exhaustion. Additionally, four consecutive lessons per teacher were filmed, and aggressive student behavior in presence of the teacher was coded by four trained external observers. The concentration of cortisol was assessed in hair samples. Results showed that teacher-perceived and observed aggression were moderately associated. Observed aggression was related to teacher perceptions to a much lesser extent than teachers' avoidant coping styles, that is, chronic worry and resignation. While teacher-perceived student aggression was associated with teachers' self-reported vital exhaustion, we did not find any significant association with hair-cortisol concentration. Our findings suggest that teachers perceive student aggression through the lens of their coping styles. Teachers' dysfunctional coping styles are associated with an overestimation of student aggression. Teachers' overestimation of student aggression relates to higher levels of vital exhaustion. Therefore, it is crucial to identify and change teachers' dysfunctional coping styles to prevent a vicious cycle of dysfunctional teacher-student interactions.
学生的攻击性行为被认为是导致教师压力的主要风险因素。然而,教师的应对方式可能会影响他们对学生攻击性行为的认知和反应。本研究旨在测试教师对学生攻击性行为的认知主要是反映在教师在场时客观观察到的攻击行为(由外部观察者编码),还是教师对学生攻击性行为的认知主要反映了教师的回避应对方式,如长期担忧和听天由命。最后,我们研究观察到的和教师感知到的攻击行为是否与教师的严重精力耗竭和心理生理压力增加有关(即头发皮质醇浓度升高)。在一项动态评估研究中,我们对42名瑞士教师进行了自我报告,以评估他们对学生攻击行为的感知、长期担忧、听天由命和严重精力耗竭情况。此外,对每位教师的连续四节课进行了拍摄,由四名训练有素的外部观察者对教师在场时学生的攻击行为进行编码。通过头发样本评估皮质醇浓度。结果表明,教师感知到的攻击行为与观察到的攻击行为呈中度相关。观察到的攻击行为与教师认知的关联程度远低于教师的回避应对方式,即长期担忧和听天由命。虽然教师感知到的学生攻击行为与教师自我报告的严重精力耗竭有关,但我们没有发现与头发皮质醇浓度有任何显著关联。我们的研究结果表明,教师通过他们的应对方式来感知学生攻击行为。教师功能失调的应对方式与对学生攻击行为的高估有关。教师对学生攻击行为的高估与更高水平的严重精力耗竭有关。因此,识别并改变教师功能失调的应对方式以防止教师与学生之间功能失调互动的恶性循环至关重要。