Department of Medical Education, Dartmouth College Geisel School of Medicine, Hanover, NH, USA.
Center for Health Professions Education, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, MD, USA.
Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 2024 May;29(2):425-441. doi: 10.1007/s10459-023-10263-6. Epub 2023 Jul 10.
While women entering medical school are faced with a patriarchal system, they also enter into a community with other women and the potential for resistance. The purpose of this study is to use the theory of temporal agency to explore how first-year medical students who identify as women draw upon past, future, and present agency to resist the patriarchal system of medicine.The data for this study were drawn from the first year (October 2020-April 2021) of a longitudinal project using narrative inquiry to understand the socialization of women students in undergraduate medical education. Fifteen participants performed two interviews and a series of written reflection prompts about their childhood and medical school experiences, each lasting approximately 45 min.Participants' resistance drew on past resources, recognizing themselves as Other, which contributed to categorically locating themselves as part of a broader resisting community, even outside their institution. They also hypothesized future possibilities as part of resistance, either an ideal future where they would exercise power, or an unchanged one and the hypothetical resolutions they would use to manage it. Finally, they contextualized past and future in the present, identifying problems to make strategic decisions and execute actions.Our creative interweaving of the constructs of temporal agency, communal agency, and resistance allows us to paint a nuanced picture of how these women conceive of themselves as part of a larger group of women amidst the hierarchical, patriarchal structures of medical school while, at times, internalizing these hierarchies.
当女性进入医学院时,她们不仅面临着父权制体系,还进入了一个由其他女性组成的社区,并有可能进行反抗。本研究旨在运用时间代理理论,探讨认同女性身份的一年级医学生如何利用过去、未来和现在的代理来反抗医学领域的父权制体系。本研究的数据来自于一项纵向项目的第一年(2020 年 10 月至 2021 年 4 月),该项目采用叙事探究来理解女性学生在本科医学教育中的社会化过程。15 名参与者进行了两次访谈,并完成了一系列关于他们童年和医学院经历的书面反思提示,每次访谈持续约 45 分钟。参与者的反抗行为利用了过去的资源,将自己视为“他者”,这有助于将自己明确地归类为更广泛的反抗社区的一部分,即使不在自己的机构内。他们还假设未来的可能性是反抗的一部分,要么是他们行使权力的理想未来,要么是不变的未来,以及他们将用来应对的假设解决方案。最后,他们将过去和未来置于当下的背景中,确定问题以做出战略决策并采取行动。我们创造性地将时间代理、共同体代理和反抗的概念融合在一起,描绘了这些女性如何在医学院的等级制、父权制结构中,将自己视为更大的女性群体的一部分,同时在某些时候内化这些等级制。