Department of General, Visceral and Transplant Surgery, University Medical Center Mainz, Mainz, Germany.
Department of General, Visceral and Transplant Surgery, University Medical Center Mainz, Mainz, Germany.
J Surg Educ. 2023 Sep;80(9):1215-1220. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2023.06.026. Epub 2023 Jul 16.
Surgical education is highly dependent on intraoperative communication. Trainers must know the trainee's training level to ensure high-quality surgical training. A systematic preoperative dialogue (Educational Team Time Out, ETO) was established to discuss the steps of each surgical procedure.
Over 6 months, ETO was performed within a time limit of 3 minutes. Digital surveys on the utility of ETO and its impact on performance were conducted immediately after surgery and at the end of the study period among the staff of the participating disciplines (trainer, trainee, surgical nursing staff, anaesthesiologists, and medical students). The number of surgical substeps performed was recorded and compared with the equivalent period one year earlier.
ETO was performed in 64 of the 103 eligible operations (62%). Liver resection (n = 37) was the most frequent procedure, followed by left-sided colorectal surgery (n = 12), partial pancreaticoduodenectomy (n = 6), right-sided hemicolectomies (n = 5), and thyroidectomies (n = 4). Anaesthesiologists most frequently reported that ETO had a direct impact on their work during surgery (90.9%). The influence scores were 46.8% for trainees, 8.8% for trainers, 53.3% for surgical nursing staff and 66.6% for medical students. During the implementation of ETO, a trend towards more assisted substeps in oncologic visceral surgery was seen compared to the corresponding period one year earlier (51% vs.40%; p = 0.11).
ETO leads to improved intraoperative communication and more performed substeps during complex procedures, which increases motivation and practical training. This concept can easily be implemented in all surgical specialties to improve surgical education.
外科教育高度依赖于术中交流。培训师必须了解学员的培训水平,以确保高质量的外科培训。建立了系统的术前对话(教育团队时间外,ETO),以讨论每个手术步骤。
在 6 个月的时间里,ETO 在 3 分钟的时间限制内进行。在手术后和研究结束时,参与学科的工作人员(培训师、学员、外科护理人员、麻醉师和医学生)立即对 ETO 的实用性及其对绩效的影响进行了数字调查。记录了执行的手术子步骤数量,并与一年前的同期进行了比较。
在 103 项符合条件的手术中有 64 项(62%)进行了 ETO。肝切除术(n=37)是最常见的手术,其次是左侧结直肠手术(n=12)、部分胰十二指肠切除术(n=6)、右侧半结肠切除术(n=5)和甲状腺切除术(n=4)。麻醉师最常报告 ETO 直接影响他们在手术期间的工作(90.9%)。影响评分分别为学员 46.8%、培训师 8.8%、外科护理人员 53.3%和医学生 66.6%。在实施 ETO 期间,与一年前的同期相比,观察到肿瘤内脏手术中的辅助子步骤呈增加趋势(51%对 40%;p=0.11)。
ETO 导致复杂手术中术中沟通得到改善,执行的子步骤增多,从而提高了积极性和实践培训。这个概念可以很容易地在所有外科专业中实施,以改善外科教育。