Kehne Adrianne, Bernstein Steven J, Thomas Jennifer, Bicket Mark C, Bohnert Amy S B, Madden Erin Fanning, Powell Victoria D, Lagisetty Pooja
Division of General Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Center for Clinical Management Research, VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
J Pain Res. 2023 Jul 10;16:2321-2330. doi: 10.2147/JPR.S406034. eCollection 2023.
About 5-8 million US patients take long-term opioid therapy for chronic pain. In the context of policies and guidelines instituted to reduce inappropriate opioid prescribing, abrupt discontinuations in opioid prescriptions have increased and many primary care clinics will not prescribe opioids for new patients, reducing access to care. This may result in uncontrolled pain and other negative outcomes, such as transition to illicit opioids. The objective of this study was to generate policy, intervention, and research recommendations to improve access to care for these patients.
We conducted a RAND/UCLA Modified Delphi, consisting of workshops, background videos and reading materials, and moderated web-based panel discussions held September 2020-January 2021. The panel consisted of 24 individuals from across Michigan, identified via expert nomination and snowball recruitment, including clinical providers, health science researchers, state-level policymakers and regulators, care coordination experts, patient advocates, payor representatives, and community and public health experts. The panel proposed intervention, policy, and research recommendations, scored the feasibility, impact, and importance of each on a 9-point scale, and ranked all recommendations by implementation priority.
The panel produced 11 final recommendations across three themes: reimbursement reform, provider education, and reducing racial inequities in care. The 3 reimbursement-focused recommendations were highest ranked (theme average = 4.2/11), including the two top-ranked recommendations: increasing reimbursement for time needed to treat complex chronic pain (ranked #1/11) and bundling payment for multimodal pain care (#2/11). Four provider education recommendations ranked slightly lower (theme average = 6.2/11) and included clarifying the spectrum of opioid dependence and training providers on multimodal treatments. Four recommendations addressed racial inequities (theme average = 7.2/11), such as standardizing pain management protocols to reduce treatment disparities.
Panelists indicated reimbursement should incentivize traditionally lower-paying evidence-based pain care, but multiple strategies may be needed to meaningfully expand access.
约500 - 800万美国患者接受长期阿片类药物治疗以缓解慢性疼痛。在为减少不适当阿片类药物处方而制定的政策和指南背景下,阿片类药物处方的突然中断有所增加,许多初级保健诊所不再为新患者开具阿片类药物,从而减少了医疗服务的可及性。这可能导致疼痛无法控制以及其他负面后果,比如转向使用非法阿片类药物。本研究的目的是提出政策、干预措施和研究建议,以改善这些患者获得医疗服务的机会。
我们开展了一项兰德/加州大学洛杉矶分校改良德尔菲法研究,包括研讨会、背景视频和阅读材料,以及于2020年9月至2021年1月举行的基于网络的小组讨论并由主持人引导。该小组由来自密歇根州各地的24人组成,通过专家提名和滚雪球式招募确定,包括临床提供者、健康科学研究人员、州级政策制定者和监管者、护理协调专家、患者权益倡导者、付款方代表以及社区和公共卫生专家。该小组提出了干预措施、政策和研究建议,对每项建议的可行性、影响和重要性进行了9分制评分,并按实施优先级对所有建议进行了排序。
该小组围绕三个主题提出了11项最终建议:报销改革、提供者教育以及减少医疗中的种族不平等。以报销为重点的3项建议排名最高(主题平均排名 = 4.2/11),包括排名前两位的建议:增加对治疗复杂慢性疼痛所需时间的报销(排名第1/11)以及对多模式疼痛护理进行捆绑支付(排名第2/11)。4项提供者教育建议排名略低(主题平均排名 = 6.2/11),包括明确阿片类药物依赖的范围以及对提供者进行多模式治疗培训。4项建议涉及种族不平等问题(主题平均排名 = 7.2/11),例如规范疼痛管理方案以减少治疗差异。
小组成员表示,报销应激励传统上支付较低的循证疼痛护理,但可能需要多种策略才能切实扩大医疗服务的可及性。