Baker Carrie K, Maniam Nivethietha, Schnapp Benjamin H, Genes Nicholas, Nielson Jeffrey A, Mohan Vishnu, Hersh William, Slovis Benjamin H
Soin Medical Center, Kettering Health, Clinical Informatics Fellowship Program, Dayton OH.
Wright State University, Department of Emergency Medicine, Dayton, OH.
J Educ Teach Emerg Med. 2022 Oct 15;7(4):C1-C50. doi: 10.21980/J82P9H. eCollection 2022 Oct.
This curriculum is designed for emergency medicine residents at all levels of training. The curriculum covers basic foundations in clinical informatics for improving patient care and outcomes, utilizing data, and leading improvements in emergency medicine.
The curriculum is designed for a four-week rotation.
The American College of Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) mandated that all Emergency Medicine (EM) residents receive specific training in the use of information technology.1,2 To our knowledge, a clinical informatics curriculum for EM residents does not exist. We propose the following standardized and reproducible educational curriculum for EM residents.
The aim of this curriculum is to teach informatics skills to emergency physicians to improve patient care and outcomes, utilize data, and develop projects to lead change.3 These goals will be achieved by providing a foundational informatics elective for EM residents that follows the delineation of practice for Clinical Informatics outlined by the American Medical Informatics Association (AMIA) and the American Board of Preventive Medicine (ABPM).4-6.
The educational strategies used in this curriculum include asynchronous learning via books, papers, videos, and websites. Residents attend administrative sessions (meetings), develop a project proposal, and participate in small group discussions.The rotation emphasizes the basic concepts surrounding clinical informatics with an emphasis on improving care delivery and outcomes, information systems, data governance and analytics, as well as leadership and professionalism. The course focuses on the practical application of these concepts, including implementation, clinical decision support, workflow analysis, privacy and security, information technology across the patient care continuum, health information exchange, data analytics, and leading change through stakeholder engagement.
An initial version of the curriculum was introduced to two separate institutions and was completed by three rotating resident physicians and one rotating resident pharmacist. A brief course evaluation as well as qualitative feedback was solicited from elective participants by the course director, via email following the completion of the course, regarding the effectiveness of the course content. Learner feedback was used to influence the development of this complete curriculum.
The curriculum was graded by learners on a 5-point Likert scale (1=strongly disagree, 5 = strongly agree). The mean response to, "This course was a valuable use of my elective time," was 5 (sd=0). The mean response to, "I achieved the learning objectives," and "This rotation helped me understand Clinical Informatics," were both 4.75 (sd=0.5).
Overall, participants reported that the content was effective for achieving the learning objectives. During initial implementation, we found that the preliminary asynchronous learning component worked less effectively than we anticipated due to a lower volume of content. In response to this, as well as resident feedback, we added significantly more educational content.In conclusion, this model curriculum provides a structured process for an informatics rotation for the emergency medicine resident that utilizes the core competencies established by the governing bodies of the clinical informatics specialty and ACGME.
Clinical informatics key concepts, including definitions, fundamental terminology, history, policy and regulations, ethical considerations, clinical decision support, health information systems, data governance and analytics, process improvement, stakeholder engagement and change management.
本课程面向各个培训阶段的急诊医学住院医师。该课程涵盖临床信息学的基础内容,以改善患者护理和治疗效果,利用数据,并引领急诊医学领域的改进。
本课程设计为四周轮转。
美国毕业后医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)规定,所有急诊医学(EM)住院医师都必须接受信息技术使用方面的特定培训。据我们所知,目前尚无针对急诊医学住院医师的临床信息学课程。我们为急诊医学住院医师提出以下标准化且可重复的教育课程。
本课程的目标是向急诊医生传授信息学技能,以改善患者护理和治疗效果,利用数据,并开展项目以引领变革。通过为急诊医学住院医师提供一门基础信息学选修课来实现这些目标,该选修课遵循美国医学信息学会(AMIA)和美国预防医学委员会(ABPM)概述的临床信息学实践描述。
本课程中使用的教育策略包括通过书籍、论文、视频和网站进行异步学习。住院医师参加行政会议,制定项目提案,并参与小组讨论。轮转强调围绕临床信息学的基本概念,重点是改善护理提供和治疗效果、信息系统、数据治理与分析,以及领导力和专业素养。该课程侧重于这些概念的实际应用,包括实施、临床决策支持、工作流程分析、隐私与安全、患者护理连续过程中的信息技术、健康信息交换、数据分析,以及通过利益相关者参与引领变革。
课程的初始版本在两个不同机构进行了介绍,由三名轮转住院医师和一名轮转住院药剂师完成。课程主任在课程结束后通过电子邮件向选修课参与者征求了简短的课程评估以及定性反馈,以了解课程内容的有效性。学习者的反馈被用于影响本完整课程的开发。
学习者对课程进行了5分制李克特量表评分(1 = 强烈不同意,5 = 强烈同意)。对于“本课程对我的选修时间利用很有价值”这一问题的平均回答为5分(标准差 = 0)。对于“我实现了学习目标”和“这次轮转有助于我理解临床信息学”这两个问题的平均回答均为4.75分(标准差 = 0.5)。
总体而言,参与者报告称该内容对于实现学习目标是有效的。在初始实施过程中,我们发现初步的异步学习部分效果不如预期,原因是内容量较少。针对此情况以及住院医师的反馈,我们大幅增加了教育内容。总之,这个示范课程为急诊医学住院医师的信息学轮转提供了一个结构化流程,该流程利用了临床信息学专业管理机构和ACGME确立的核心能力。
临床信息学关键概念,包括定义、基本术语、历史、政策与法规、伦理考量、临床决策支持、健康信息系统、数据治理与分析、流程改进、利益相关者参与和变革管理。