Division of Neurology, Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Damascus University, Damascus, Syrian Arab Republic
Division of Pulmonology, Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Damascus University, Damascus, Syrian Arab Republic.
BMJ Open. 2023 Jul 20;13(7):e065280. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-065280.
The decade-long Syrian war led to fragile health infrastructures lacking in personal and physical resources. The public health of the Syrian population was, therefore, vulnerable to the COVID-19 pandemic, which devastated even well-resourced healthcare systems. Nevertheless, the officially reported incidence and fatality rates were significantly lower than the forecasted numbers.
A retrospective cohort study.
The four main responding hospitals in Damascus, which received most of the cases during the first pandemic wave in Syria (i.e., June-August 2020).
One thousand one hundred eighty-four patients who were managed as inpatient COVID-19 cases.
The records of hospitalised patients were screened for clinical history, vital signs, diagnosis modality, major interventions and status at discharge.
The diagnostic and therapeutic preparedness for COVID-19 was significantly heterogeneous among the different centres and depleted rapidly after the arrival of the first wave. Only 32% of the patients were diagnosed based on positive reverse transcription-PCR tests. Five hundred twenty-six patients had an indication for intensive care unit admission, but only 82% of them received it. Two hundred fifty-seven patients needed mechanical ventilation, but ventilators were not available to 14% of them, all of whom died. Overall mortality during hospitalisation reached 46% and no significant difference was found in fatality between those who received and did not receive these care options.
The Syrian healthcare system expressed minor resilience in facing the COVID-19 pandemic, as its assets vanished swiftly with a limited number of cases. This forced physicians to reserve resources (e.g., ventilators) for the most severe cases, which led to poor outcomes of in-hospital management and limited the admission capacity for milder cases. The overwhelmed system additionally suffered from constrained coordination, suboptimal allocation of the accessible resources and a severe inability to informatively report on the catastrophic pandemic course in Syria.
长达十年的叙利亚战争导致医疗基础设施脆弱,人员和物力资源匮乏。叙利亚民众的公共卫生因此容易受到 COVID-19 大流行的影响,而 COVID-19 大流行甚至摧毁了资源充足的医疗保健系统。然而,官方报告的发病率和死亡率明显低于预测数字。
回顾性队列研究。
大马士革的四家主要应对医院,这些医院在叙利亚第一波大流行期间(即 2020 年 6 月至 8 月)接收了大部分病例。
1184 名作为 COVID-19 住院患者管理的患者。
筛选住院患者的病历以获取临床病史、生命体征、诊断方式、主要干预措施和出院情况。
不同中心对 COVID-19 的诊断和治疗准备工作差异很大,并且在第一波疫情到来后迅速枯竭。只有 32%的患者是根据阳性逆转录-聚合酶链反应(RT-PCR)检测结果确诊的。526 名患者有入住重症监护病房(ICU)的指征,但只有 82%的患者入住。257 名患者需要机械通气,但其中 14%的患者没有呼吸机,他们全部死亡。住院期间的总死亡率达到 46%,接受和未接受这些治疗选择的患者死亡率没有显著差异。
叙利亚医疗保健系统在应对 COVID-19 大流行方面表现出较小的弹性,因为其资产在病例数量有限的情况下迅速消失。这迫使医生为最严重的病例保留资源(例如呼吸机),导致住院管理结果不佳,并限制了轻症病例的入院能力。不堪重负的系统还受到协调受限、可用资源配置不佳以及无法向叙利亚灾难性的大流行进程提供信息报告的严重影响。