The James Cook University Hospital, South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Middlesbrough, UK.
Centre for Applied Psychological Science, Teesside University, Middlesbrough, UK.
Prog Transplant. 2023 Sep;33(3):208-215. doi: 10.1177/15269248231189869. Epub 2023 Jul 20.
In England, everyone is considered an organ donor unless they have registered for opt-out donation. This study evaluated positive statements and negative affective attitudes against anticipated organ donor status and whether the order in the attitudes and statements presented impacted organ donor intention under an opt-out system. A quasi-experimental mixed between-within design was employed with participants assigned to 1 of 2 conditions. Participants in the first condition received negative affective attitude statements followed by positive statements. This was reversed in the second condition to combat ordering effects. Participants ( = 679) were asked about their donor status under an opt-out system. There were three groups: opt-in (actively), opt-out/not sure, and deemed consent (no objection). Organ donor intentions were measured at three intervals: baseline, post-positive statements, and post-negative attitudes. Approximately 10% of participants would opt-out or were unsure of their intentions to be an organ donor under an opt-out system. Significant effects were found in both positive statements and negative affective attitudes. All groups expressed greater medical mistrust and were most influenced by cognitive attitudes. Under the opt-out system in England, it is anticipated that the majority would actively opt-in or have no objection to being automatically registered as an organ donor. Public health campaigns would benefit from promoting the most influential positive statements and refuting the most detrimental negative attitudes to increase intentions of those who plan to opt-out or are unsure.
在英国,每个人都被视为器官捐献者,除非他们已登记选择退出捐献。本研究评估了对预期器官捐献者身份的正面陈述和负面情感态度,以及在选择退出系统下,态度和陈述呈现的顺序是否会影响器官捐献者的意愿。采用了准实验混合前后设计,参与者被分配到 2 种条件之一。第一种条件的参与者先接受负面情感态度陈述,然后是正面陈述。第二种条件则相反,以克服顺序效应。参与者(n=679)被要求在选择退出系统下表达他们的捐献者身份。有三个组:主动选择(积极)、选择退出/不确定和默认同意(无反对)。在三个时间点测量器官捐献者的意愿:基线、正面陈述后和负面态度后。约 10%的参与者在选择退出系统下会选择退出或不确定是否愿意成为器官捐献者。在正面陈述和负面情感态度方面都发现了显著影响。所有组都表达了更多的医疗不信任,并且最容易受到认知态度的影响。在英国的选择退出系统下,预计大多数人会积极选择或对自动登记为器官捐献者没有异议。公共卫生运动将受益于推广最具影响力的正面陈述,并反驳最具危害性的负面态度,以增加那些计划选择退出或不确定的人的意愿。