Department of Developmental and Educational Psychology, University of Granada, Granada, Spain.
Department of Personality, Evaluation, and Psychological Treatment, University of Granada, Granada, Spain.
Clin Linguist Phon. 2024 Sep;38(9):819-837. doi: 10.1080/02699206.2023.2237647. Epub 2023 Jul 21.
Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and Developmental Language Disorder (DLD) have traditionally been considered separate disorders, although some similarities and overlaps in certain aspects of language have been detected. In this paper, we compare the deficits in receptive grammar in these two disorders. We analyse the proportion of grammatical errors in relation to semantic complexity in 84 children divided into four groups: children with autism language impairment (ALI), with autism language normal (ALN), with DLD, and with typical development (TD), all groups with the same age of receptive vocabulary. The results show significant differences in the comprehension of grammatical structures, both simple (canonical and non-reversible) and complex (non-canonical and reversible). Children with ASD and DLD show different language profiles depending on the syntactic complexity. In the simplest structures, no differences are found between the groups, starting at an equivalent vocabulary age of 7:8 years. However, there are differences between the ALI and DLD groups with respect to the TD group in the more complex structures, starting at an equivalent vocabulary age of 3 years. Therefore, both groups ALI and DLD present the greatest difficulties compared to ALN and TD. The paper discusses the importance of attending to these differences, since the repercussion of comprehension difficulties increases as children grow.
自闭症谱系障碍 (ASD) 和发育性语言障碍 (DLD) 传统上被认为是两种不同的疾病,尽管在语言的某些方面已经检测到一些相似之处和重叠。在本文中,我们比较了这两种疾病在接受性语法方面的缺陷。我们分析了 84 名儿童的语法错误比例与语义复杂性的关系,这些儿童分为四组:具有自闭症语言障碍 (ALI) 的儿童、具有自闭症语言正常 (ALN) 的儿童、具有 DLD 的儿童和具有典型发展 (TD) 的儿童,所有这些组都具有相同的接受性词汇年龄。结果表明,在简单 (规范和不可逆) 和复杂 (非规范和可逆) 语法结构的理解方面存在显著差异。患有 ASD 和 DLD 的儿童根据语法复杂性表现出不同的语言特征。在最简单的结构中,从词汇年龄为 7 岁开始,各组之间没有差异。然而,在更复杂的结构中,ALI 和 DLD 组与 TD 组之间存在差异,从词汇年龄为 3 岁开始。因此,与 ALN 和 TD 相比,这两个组的 ALI 和 DLD 都存在最大的困难。本文讨论了注意这些差异的重要性,因为随着儿童的成长,理解困难的影响会增加。