Newble D I, Clarke R M
Med Educ. 1986 Jul;20(4):267-73. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.1986.tb01365.x.
The way in which students approach their learning is dependent on a variety of factors including the characteristics of the departments and teaching to which they are exposed. These factors appear to influence whether the students adopt a surface, deep or strategic approach. In order to explore further the relationship between educational context and approach to learning, a comparison was made between students attending a traditional medical school and those attending a problem-based medical school. The results showed marked differences, with the problem-based school being higher on deep approach and lower on surface approach than the traditional school. This study provides one of the first pieces of evidence of a difference between students in the two types of medical school which can be directly attributed to the educational environment. Students in the problem-based school appear to have an approach to learning which more closely approximates the aims of most medical schools. The results provide support for the philosophies and strategies of the problem-based schools.
学生对待学习的方式取决于多种因素,包括他们所接触的院系特点和教学方式。这些因素似乎会影响学生是采用表层、深层还是策略性学习方式。为了进一步探究教育背景与学习方式之间的关系,对就读于传统医学院的学生和就读于基于问题的医学院的学生进行了比较。结果显示出显著差异,基于问题的医学院的学生在深层学习方式上得分更高,在表层学习方式上得分低于传统医学院。这项研究首次提供了证据,证明两种类型医学院的学生之间存在差异,且这种差异可直接归因于教育环境。基于问题的医学院的学生似乎有一种更接近大多数医学院目标的学习方式。研究结果为基于问题的医学院的理念和策略提供了支持。