UEF Law School, University of Eastern Finland, Joensuu, Finland.
Health Care Services for Prisoners, Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland.
Int J Prison Health. 2023 Jul 25;ahead-of-print(ahead-of-print):641-652. doi: 10.1108/IJPH-05-2022-0032.
Globally, health problems are very common among prisoners. A mental state examination aims to help in recognising psychiatric problems among offenders and the possible association of these psychiatric issues with their committed crime. The legal-medical term "reduced criminal responsibility" refers to a weakened sense of reality and the ability to control one's behaviour because of compromised mental health and without an evaluated need for forensic psychiatric hospitalisation. However, little is known about the actual need for the health care of prisoners with reduced criminal responsibility (PRCR). The purpose of this study was to explore treatment-related visits to prison by PRCR in Finland.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: The research data comprise information on PRCR's treatment-related visits and that of a matched control group ( = 222). Descriptive cross-tabulation with X²- and nonparametric Mann-Whitney U-tests and Cox regression analyses are applied.
The results show that almost every PRCR had at least one treatment-related visit during their sentences. Visits to a psychiatric hospital for prisoners, to the prison hospital and especially to a civil hospital are more common among PRCR. The need for treatment appears significantly earlier in their sentences.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: These findings demonstrate the PRCR's greater need for access to health services and the need for further development between the Health Care Services for Prisoners, Prison and Probation Service of Finland and public health and social services in Finland. More exploration of the medical reasons and locational distribution of the vast amount of civil hospitalisation is needed.
在全球范围内,囚犯的健康问题非常普遍。精神状态检查旨在帮助识别罪犯中的精神问题,以及这些精神问题与他们所犯罪行之间的可能关联。法律医学术语“减轻刑事责任”是指由于心理健康受损和没有评估需要法医精神病院住院治疗而导致的现实感和行为控制能力减弱。然而,对于减轻刑事责任的囚犯(PRCR)的实际医疗保健需求知之甚少。本研究旨在探讨芬兰 PRCR 的治疗相关就诊情况。
设计/方法/方法:研究数据包括 PRCR 的治疗相关就诊信息和匹配对照组(n=222)的信息。采用 X²检验和非参数曼-惠特尼 U 检验以及 Cox 回归分析进行描述性交叉表分析。
结果表明,PRCR 在服刑期间几乎每次都有至少一次治疗相关就诊。囚犯去精神病院、监狱医院,尤其是去综合医院就诊的情况更为常见。在服刑期间,对治疗的需求出现得更早。
原创性/价值:这些发现表明,PRCR 对获得医疗服务的需求更大,需要芬兰囚犯医疗保健服务、监狱和缓刑服务与芬兰公共卫生和社会服务之间进一步发展。需要进一步探索大量综合医院就诊的医学原因和位置分布。