Younginer Nicholas A, Draper Carrie L
J Acad Nutr Diet. 2024 Feb;124(2):169-180. doi: 10.1016/j.jand.2023.07.016. Epub 2023 Jul 22.
The United States Department of Agriculture expanded the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP)-Ed program to all 50 states in 2004. In 2010, the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act required that agencies implementing SNAP-Ed support policy, systems, and environmental (PSE) strategies, in addition to providing direct education (DE). Research has evaluated the impact of PSEs on health, but few studies have investigated the process of PSE implementation.
The objective of this study was to identify facilitators and barriers to PSE implementation at SNAP-Ed partner sites from the perspectives of site contacts and SNAP-Ed implementers.
This study employed a qualitative longitudinal design. The PSE planning and implementation process was observed over 1 year at SNAP-Ed partner sites. Semistructured interviews were conducted with site contacts and SNAP-Ed implementers throughout the year.
PARTICIPANTS/SETTING: Participants were SNAP-Ed implementers (n = 8) and site contacts (n = 18) from 18 partner sites where both PSE and direct education were occurring. SNAP-Ed implementers were debriefed once, and site contacts were interviewed three times over the course of the study. This study was conducted in a Southern US state with SNAP-Ed partner sites that intended to implement PSEs. The duration of data collection was October 2017 through September 2018.
A thematic analysis of barriers and facilitators to PSE implementation across sites was conducted.
The PSE implementation barriers were lack of site or implementer readiness or capacity; breakdowns in communication; and DE prioritized over PSE. Facilitators were effective communication; site capacity or readiness; and alignment between site and SNAP-Ed goals.
Communication, capacity, and coordination between SNAP-Ed and partner sites were key components over the timeline of PSE planning and potential implementation.
美国农业部于2004年将补充营养援助计划教育项目(SNAP-Ed)扩展至全美50个州。2010年,《健康、无饥饿儿童法案》要求实施SNAP-Ed的机构除提供直接教育(DE)外,还要支持政策、系统和环境(PSE)策略。已有研究评估了PSE对健康的影响,但很少有研究调查PSE的实施过程。
本研究的目的是从站点联系人及SNAP-Ed实施者的角度,确定SNAP-Ed合作站点实施PSE的促进因素和障碍。
本研究采用定性纵向设计。在SNAP-Ed合作站点对PSE规划和实施过程进行了为期1年的观察。全年与站点联系人及SNAP-Ed实施者进行了半结构化访谈。
参与者/设置:参与者为来自18个同时开展PSE和直接教育的合作站点的SNAP-Ed实施者(n = 8)和站点联系人(n = 18)。在研究过程中,对SNAP-Ed实施者进行了一次汇报,对站点联系人进行了三次访谈。本研究在美国南部一个州进行,该州的SNAP-Ed合作站点打算实施PSE。数据收集时间为2017年10月至2018年9月。
对各站点PSE实施的障碍和促进因素进行了主题分析。
PSE实施的障碍包括站点或实施者准备不足或能力欠缺;沟通不畅;以及直接教育优先于PSE。促进因素包括有效的沟通;站点能力或准备情况;以及站点与SNAP-Ed目标的一致性。
在PSE规划和潜在实施的时间范围内,SNAP-Ed与合作站点之间的沟通、能力和协调是关键要素。