Department of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine, Amsterdam University Medical Centers, VU Medical Center Amsterdam, Cancer Center Amsterdam, De Boelelaan 1117, 1081 HV, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
NWZ Group, Alkmaar, The Netherlands.
Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2023 Sep;46(9):1257-1266. doi: 10.1007/s00270-023-03508-9. Epub 2023 Jul 25.
This study assessed the diagnostic value of CT hepatic arteriography (CTHA) for the intraprocedural detection of previously unknown colorectal liver metastases (CRLM) and the impact on the definitive treatment plan.
All patients treated with CTHA-guided percutaneous ablation for CRLM between January 2012 and March 2022 were identified from the Amsterdam Colorectal Liver Met Registry (AmCORE). Radiology reports of the ablative procedure and follow-up imaging were reviewed to see if (a) previously unknown CRLM were detected intra-procedurally and if (b) new CRLM, potentially missed on CTHA, appeared within 6 months following the procedure; three abdominal radiologists re-reviewed the baseline CTHA scans of these patients with early recurrence. To ratify immediate ablations of concomitantly detected CRLM, the upper limit of false positives was predefined at 10%.
One hundred and fifty-two patients were included. With CTHA, a total of 17 additional tumours in 15 patients were diagnosed and treated immediately, two representing disappeared tumours following systemic chemotherapy. Compared to the conventional contrast-enhanced (ce)CT, ceMRI and 18F-FDG PET-CT, adding CTHA was superior for the detection of CRLM (P < .001). Within 12 months of follow-up 121, new CRLM appeared in 49/152 patients (32.2%); retrospective blinded assessment revealed 56 to already be visible on the baseline CTHA scan (46%); four lesions without substrate on follow-up scans were considered false positives (n = 4/60; 7%). Arterial ring enhancement was the most frequently reported imaging characteristic (n = 45/60; 75%).
The subsequent use of CTHA has added value for the detection of previously unknown and vanished CRLM. Taking into account the low number of false positives (7%) and the favourable safety profile of percutaneous ablation, we believe that immediate ablation of typical ring-enhancing supplementary tumours is justified and sufficiently validated.
Level 3; individual cross-sectional study with consistently applied reference standard and blinding.
本研究评估了 CT 肝动脉造影(CTHA)在术中检测先前未知结直肠肝转移(CRLM)中的诊断价值,并评估其对明确治疗计划的影响。
从阿姆斯特丹结直肠肝转移登记处(AmCORE)中确定了 2012 年 1 月至 2022 年 3 月期间接受 CTHA 引导的经皮消融治疗的所有 CRLM 患者。回顾消融术中和随访影像学的放射学报告,以了解是否(a)术中检测到先前未知的 CRLM,以及(b)新的 CRLM 是否在术后 6 个月内出现,这些新的 CRLM 可能在 CTHA 上漏诊;三位腹部放射科医生重新审查了这些早期复发患者的基线 CTHA 扫描。为了证实同时发现的 CRLM 的即刻消融,假阳性的上限预先设定为 10%。
共纳入 152 名患者。通过 CTHA,在 15 名患者中总共诊断出 17 个额外肿瘤并立即进行治疗,其中 2 个为系统性化疗后消失的肿瘤。与常规增强 CT(ceCT)、ceMRI 和 18F-FDG PET-CT 相比,添加 CTHA 可提高 CRLM 的检测率(P<0.001)。在 12 个月的随访中,152 名患者中有 49 名(32.2%)出现新的 CRLM;回顾性盲法评估显示,基线 CTHA 扫描上已经可见 56 个(46%);60 个中有 4 个在随访扫描上无病灶,被认为是假阳性(n=4/60;7%)。动脉环强化是最常报道的影像学特征(n=45/60;75%)。
后续使用 CTHA 可提高对先前未知和消失的 CRLM 的检测能力。考虑到假阳性率较低(7%)和经皮消融术的良好安全性,我们认为,对典型的环形强化辅助肿瘤进行即刻消融是合理的,且具有充分的验证依据。
3 级;采用一致的参考标准和盲法的个体横断面研究。