Wang Yurou, Zhang Haobo, Wang Jue, Ma Xiaofeng
School of Psychology, Northwest Normal University, Lanzhou 730070, China.
Key Laboratory of Behavioral and Mental Health, Lanzhou 730070, China.
J Intell. 2023 Jul 4;11(7):131. doi: 10.3390/jintelligence11070131.
The hypermedia environment is among the most prevalent contemporary self-regulated learning (SRL) environments; however, methods for improving the effectiveness of students' multi-session SRL in such environments remain under discussion. In this study, two experiments were conducted to explore whether and how prompts and feedback benefit performance during multi-session SRL in a hypermedia learning environment. A total of 76 senior students participated in Experiment 1, which used a mixed 2 (prompting condition: prompt, no prompt) × 2 (feedback condition: feedback, no feedback) × 2 (learning session: Session 1 and Session 2) design to explore the effects of prompting and feedback on the multi-session learning process in a hypermedia environment. The results indicated that, in learning Session 1, performance in the prompt condition was significantly better than in the unprompted condition, with or without feedback; in learning Session 2, participants in the prompt condition with feedback performed significantly better than those in the other three conditions. Students in the group with a prompt and feedback had the most accurate meta-comprehension absolute accuracy in both learning sessions. Experiment 2 recruited 94 secondary school students to further explore whether the combination of prompts and different types of feedback led to different learning outcomes according to the division of feedback timing. A mixed 2 (prompt condition: prompt, no prompt) × 3 (feedback condition: delayed feedback, immediate feedback, no feedback) × 2 (learning session: Session 1 and Session 2) design was used. The results indicated that, in learning Session 1, the prompt condition outperformed the unprompted condition with or without feedback; in learning Session 2, students with prompted delayed feedback outperformed the other five conditions. We also found that although there was no significant difference in meta-comprehension monitoring accuracy between delayed and immediate feedback, both groups performed significantly better than those in the no feedback condition. These results suggest that the combination of prompts and feedback in hypermedia environments facilitates student performance better than prompts or feedback alone; this improvement may be related to the correction of poor internal student feedback.
超媒体环境是当代最普遍的自我调节学习(SRL)环境之一;然而,在这种环境中提高学生多阶段自我调节学习有效性的方法仍在讨论之中。在本研究中,进行了两项实验,以探讨在超媒体学习环境中,提示和反馈在多阶段自我调节学习过程中是否以及如何对学习表现产生助益。共有76名高年级学生参与了实验1,该实验采用2(提示条件:有提示、无提示)×2(反馈条件:有反馈、无反馈)×2(学习阶段:第1阶段和第2阶段)的混合设计,以探究提示和反馈对超媒体环境中多阶段学习过程的影响。结果表明,在第1阶段学习中,无论有无反馈,有提示条件下的学习表现均显著优于无提示条件;在第2阶段学习中,有反馈的提示条件下的参与者表现显著优于其他三种条件。在两个学习阶段中,有提示和反馈组的学生元理解绝对准确性最高。实验2招募了94名中学生,以进一步探讨根据反馈时机划分,提示与不同类型反馈的组合是否会导致不同的学习结果。采用2(提示条件:有提示、无提示)×3(反馈条件:延迟反馈、即时反馈、无反馈)×2(学习阶段:第1阶段和第2阶段)的混合设计。结果表明,在第1阶段学习中,无论有无反馈,有提示条件均优于无提示条件;在第2阶段学习中,有提示的延迟反馈组学生表现优于其他五种条件。我们还发现,虽然延迟反馈和即时反馈在元理解监测准确性上没有显著差异,但两组的表现均显著优于无反馈组。这些结果表明,在超媒体环境中,提示和反馈的组合比单独的提示或反馈更能促进学生的表现;这种提升可能与纠正学生不良的内部反馈有关。