Kirkpatrick Laura, Goldman Paula, Bell Lauren Arnold, Tyler Crystal Pirtle, Harrison Elizabeth, Russell Margaret, Syed Tahniat, Szoko Nicholas, Kazmerski Traci M
Department of Pediatrics, UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Department of Pediatrics, Riley Children's Hospital, 705 Riley Hospital Drive, Indianapolis, IN, USA.
J Med Educ Curric Dev. 2023 Jul 27;10:23821205231190476. doi: 10.1177/23821205231190476. eCollection 2023 Jan-Dec.
The engagement of community partners, including patients, is increasingly recognized as important in developing medical education curricula. Structured methodology for partner engagement in curriculum development is lacking in the existing literature. This article describes a structured approach to engaging community partners to provide input on revising a curriculum for pediatric residents about pregnancy options counseling with adolescents.
We used the five-step Method for Program Adaptation through Community Engagement: (1) development of a panel of community partners including patients and professionals, (2) and (3) partner evaluation of the existing curriculum and recommendations for revisions, (4) summarization of partner feedback, and (5) development of the revised curriculum. We surveyed partners about their perceived impact on the revision and satisfaction with the process.
Seventeen partners participated. Five experienced adolescent pregnancy, while the remaining 12 included healthcare and social service professionals. All partners provided multiple recommendations, generating 124 discrete recommendations. Twenty recommendations were suggested by multiple individuals. The authors reviewed all recommendations by category during consensus meetings and determined which recommendations would be incorporated into the revised curriculum to meet stated learning objectives. We implemented 14 of these 20 recommendations, including adding a values clarification exercise, information about mental health crisis resources, and more detail about adoption. We also incorporated 15 individual recommendations pertaining to curriculum clarity. Recommendations from professionals and patients were similar. Fourteen out of 17 participants completed the survey at the close of the project. All respondents understood their roles, were satisfied with their degree of engagement, and felt that their expectations for participation were met or exceeded.
This study describes a methodology for a formal process to engage community partners in curriculum development and revision processes. Such methodology can ensure that medical education curricula are optimally attuned to the needs of key community members and integrate the patient's voice.
包括患者在内的社区合作伙伴的参与,在医学教育课程开发中日益被视为至关重要。现有文献缺乏社区合作伙伴参与课程开发的结构化方法。本文描述了一种结构化方法,用于让社区合作伙伴参与为儿科住院医师修订青少年妊娠选择咨询课程提供意见。
我们采用了通过社区参与进行项目调整的五步方法:(1)组建包括患者和专业人员在内的社区合作伙伴小组,(2)和(3)合作伙伴对现有课程进行评估并提出修订建议,(4)汇总合作伙伴的反馈意见,以及(5)开发修订后的课程。我们就合作伙伴对修订的感知影响以及对该过程的满意度进行了调查。
17名合作伙伴参与其中。5人有青少年怀孕经历,其余12人包括医疗保健和社会服务专业人员。所有合作伙伴都提出了多项建议,共产生了124条不同的建议。有20条建议是多人提出的。作者在共识会议期间按类别审查了所有建议,并确定哪些建议将纳入修订后的课程以实现既定的学习目标。我们实施了这20条建议中的14条,包括增加一次价值观澄清练习、关于心理健康危机资源的信息以及关于收养的更多细节。我们还纳入了15条与课程清晰度相关的个人建议。专业人员和患者的建议相似。17名参与者中有14人在项目结束时完成了调查。所有受访者都清楚自己的角色,对参与程度感到满意,并认为他们的参与期望得到了满足或超出。
本研究描述了一种让社区合作伙伴参与课程开发和修订过程的正式方法。这种方法可以确保医学教育课程最佳地契合关键社区成员的需求,并融入患者的声音。