McPherson Lynne, Vosz Meaghan, Gatwiri Kathomi, Hitchcock Clarissa, Tucci Joe, Mitchell Janise, Fernandes Cyra, Macnamara Noel
Southern Cross University, Gold Coast, QLD, Australia.
Australian Childhood Foundation, Ringwood, VIC, Australia.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2024 Apr;25(2):1585-1598. doi: 10.1177/15248380231189293. Epub 2023 Aug 3.
This paper reports the findings of a project that conducted a rapid review of evidence regarding assessment and intervention approaches responding to children and young people who engage in harmful sexual behaviors. A literature review was conducted using a systematic search of academic databases and consultation with subject matter experts. The process resulted in 27 scholarly publications being included and analyzed to explore what was known about effective approaches with children and young people who have engaged in harmful sexual behavior. The review found that the current state of knowledge was limited, with few of the included papers reporting research outcomes. In the absence of a sound evidence base, additional theoretical literature and expert commentary have been drawn upon to better understand issues in this complex practice area. A key finding of this review was that growing awareness that children and young people who engage in harmful sexual behaviors are, first and foremost, children. They should not be regarded as soon-to-be-adults who are engaging in adult offending. This shift in thinking informs contemporary assessment and intervention approaches, challenging those models that previously focused on measuring risk using forensic approaches to predict the likelihood of future offending. A critical failure to understand the needs of specific cohorts of children and young people was also evident.
本文报告了一个项目的研究结果,该项目对有关针对实施有害性行为的儿童和青少年的评估及干预方法的证据进行了快速审查。通过对学术数据库进行系统检索并咨询主题专家开展了文献综述。该过程最终纳入并分析了27篇学术出版物,以探究对于曾实施有害性行为的儿童和青少年的有效方法的了解情况。审查发现,目前的知识状况有限,纳入的论文中很少有报告研究结果的。在缺乏可靠证据基础的情况下,已借鉴更多的理论文献和专家评论来更好地理解这一复杂实践领域中的问题。本次审查的一个关键发现是,人们越来越意识到,实施有害性行为的儿童和青少年首先是儿童。他们不应被视为即将成年且实施成人犯罪行为的人。这种思维转变为当代评估和干预方法提供了依据,对那些以前专注于使用法医方法衡量风险以预测未来犯罪可能性的模式提出了挑战。未能理解特定儿童和青少年群体需求的严重问题也很明显。