Hu Tina Y, Surampudy Abhishek, Divatia Himani, Friedland Allen R
Internal Medicine-Pediatrics, ChristianaCare/Nemours Children's Hospital, Delaware, Newark, USA.
Internal Medicine-Pediatrics, ChristianaCare, Newark, USA.
Cureus. 2023 Jun 30;15(6):e41205. doi: 10.7759/cureus.41205. eCollection 2023 Jun.
Physician burnout impacts care (of self and patient), productivity, longevity of career, and overall cost to the system. While burnout rates for pediatricians are lower than average, they have not improved significantly over time. While strategies at the system level have been more successful than those at the individual level, both aspects are vital. This quality improvement study explores physician wellness and burnout trends of a sample population of pediatricians at the 2018 and 2019 AAP National Conference and Exhibition (NCE), using the Physician Health and Wellness Booth (PHWB). A rapid cycle approach with the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) framework was utilized. The aim was to observe if reported burnout decreased by 20% over six months. Of the pediatricians who interacted with the PHWB, 56 were randomly selected to participate. This included men and women and those in various practice settings, ranging from resident physicians to providers in practice for over 20 years. Baseline surveys included elements from a modified Maslach Burnout Inventory and the Stanford Physician Wellness Survey, focusing on burnout components (emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and fulfillment) and wellness activities. Individual-based interventions were provided at the PHWB, including adult preventative health guidelines, resources on sleep, stress mitigation, and complementary medicine. Participants received a movie ticket and Starbucks gift card. Follow-up included six monthly newsletters with strategies from seven wellness domains. Post-intervention surveys at six months assessed all baseline questions plus the effectiveness of monthly newsletters. A second PDCA cycle was conducted from the 2019 NCE. All individual-based interventions continued with an added aromatherapy oil station. Additional system-based resources included sample institutional wellness initiatives and burnout cost analyses, all focusing on advocating for cultural change at their respective home organizations. Interactive monthly wellness calendars addressing seven wellness domains were emailed for six months follow-up. Results from 10 post-intervention surveys (10/56=18% of respondents) from the initial cohort reported an average of 25% decrease in burnout (p=0.09). This was measured on a scale of 1-10 (from "never" burned out to "very often") and improved from 6.68 ("sometimes" to "often" burned out) to 5.0 ("rarely" to "sometimes" burned out). Results from Cohort 2 reflected a decrease in burnout from 4.94 ("rarely" to "sometimes" burned out) to 2.85 ("never" to "rarely" burned out) in return from 20 post-intervention surveys (20/48=42% of respondents, p=0.003). Participants noted a lack of control over work schedules and a disconnect with organizational values as drivers of burnout. Both the PHWB and monthly newsletters were rated as valuable as reminders about wellness practices. Limitations included low response rate, which was notable, and inability to prove causation of improvement from our intervention. Future steps include utilizing subject identification numbers to allow for anonymity in a prospective cohort study with a third PDCA cycle. This would allow anonymous but matched same-subject comparison of pre- and post-survey results despite the small sample size. Follow-up incentives could be beneficial. Lastly, data from both cohorts revealed the highest level of burnout in early career physicians within 10 years of training, paving an opportunity for future study.
医生职业倦怠会影响(自身及患者的)护理、工作效率、职业生涯长度以及整个医疗系统的总体成本。虽然儿科医生的职业倦怠率低于平均水平,但随着时间推移,这一情况并未显著改善。虽然系统层面的策略比个人层面的策略更成功,但两个层面都至关重要。这项质量改进研究利用医生健康与福祉展位(PHWB),探讨了2018年和2019年美国儿科学会全国会议暨展览(NCE)上儿科医生样本群体的健康状况和职业倦怠趋势。研究采用了计划-执行-检查-行动(PDCA)框架的快速循环方法。目的是观察报告的职业倦怠在六个月内是否降低20%。与PHWB互动的儿科医生中,随机选取了56人参与。这包括男性和女性,以及处于各种执业环境的医生,从住院医师到执业超过20年的医疗服务提供者。基线调查包括来自改良版马氏职业倦怠量表和斯坦福医生健康调查的内容,重点关注职业倦怠的组成部分(情感耗竭、去个性化和成就感)以及健康活动。在PHWB提供基于个人的干预措施,包括成人预防性健康指南、睡眠、压力缓解和补充医学方面的资源。参与者获得一张电影票和一张星巴克礼品卡。后续跟进包括六个月的时事通讯,内容涵盖七个健康领域的策略。六个月后的干预后调查评估了所有基线问题以及每月时事通讯的效果。从2019年NCE开始进行第二个PDCA循环。所有基于个人的干预措施继续进行,并增设了一个香薰油站。额外的基于系统的资源包括机构健康倡议样本和职业倦怠成本分析,所有这些都侧重于在各自的所属机构倡导文化变革。针对七个健康领域的互动式每月健康日历通过电子邮件发送,进行为期六个月的跟进。初始队列的10份干预后调查结果(10/56 = 18%的受访者)显示,职业倦怠平均降低了25%(p = 0.09)。这是在1至10的量表上衡量的(从“从未”倦怠到“非常频繁”倦怠),从6.68(“有时”倦怠到“经常”倦怠)改善到5.0(“很少”倦怠到“有时”倦怠)。第二组的结果显示,在20份干预后调查(20/48 = 42%的受访者,p = 0.003)后,职业倦怠从4.94(“很少”倦怠到“有时”倦怠)降至2.85(“从未”倦怠到“很少”倦怠)。参与者指出,对工作时间表缺乏控制以及与组织价值观脱节是职业倦怠的驱动因素。PHWB和每月时事通讯都被评为对健康实践提醒很有价值。局限性包括显著的低回复率,以及无法证明我们的干预与改善之间存在因果关系。未来的步骤包括在第三个PDCA循环的前瞻性队列研究中使用受试者识别号码以保证匿名性。尽管样本量小,但这将允许对调查前后结果进行匿名但匹配的同受试者比较。后续跟进激励措施可能会有帮助。最后,两组数据都显示,在接受培训的10年内,早期职业医生的职业倦怠程度最高,这为未来的研究提供了契机。