Department of Psychology, University of New Brunswick.
Can J Exp Psychol. 2023 Sep;77(3):163-176. doi: 10.1037/cep0000309. Epub 2023 Aug 3.
The present study aimed to extend the work on the curve tracing task from Voyer and MacPherson (2020) in two experiments replacing the chronometric task they used with a psychometric mental rotation task. Both experiments also manipulated separation between the target and distractor curve to confirm that a zoom lens strategy is used in curve tracing and that this strategy preference is more common for men than women. Experiment 1 also aimed to replicate the correlation between curve tracing and Navon task performance, whereas Experiment 2 determined whether the correlation between curve tracing and mental rotation remained when the attention component was partialed out. In Experiment 1, 49 men and 67 women completed the curve tracing task, the Navon task, and the Mental Rotations Test (MRT). In Experiment 2, 69 men and 66 women completed the curve tracing task, the MRT, and the Sustained Attention to Response Task (SART). Results in both experiments replicated the effect of distance between dots on the curve and the performance advantage for men in curve tracing. All tasks correlated significantly with each other at least on accuracy. Findings for the distractor curve manipulation replicated support for the use of a zoom lens strategy. However, findings for women and men produced contradictory findings. Finally, partialing out SART performance did not affect the correlation between curve tracing and MRT performance. The discussion emphasizes the common piecemeal processing component in curve tracing and mental rotation. More work is required to examine further potential sex differences in strategy use. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
本研究旨在通过两项实验扩展 Voyer 和 MacPherson(2020 年)在曲线追踪任务上的工作,这两项实验用心理旋转任务代替了他们使用的计时任务。两个实验还操纵了目标和干扰曲线之间的分离程度,以确认在曲线追踪中使用了变焦镜头策略,并且这种策略偏好男性比女性更为常见。实验 1 还旨在复制曲线追踪与纳文任务表现之间的相关性,而实验 2 则确定当注意力成分被部分排除时,曲线追踪和心理旋转之间的相关性是否仍然存在。在实验 1 中,49 名男性和 67 名女性完成了曲线追踪任务、纳文任务和心理旋转测试(MRT)。在实验 2 中,69 名男性和 66 名女性完成了曲线追踪任务、MRT 和持续注意反应任务(SART)。两个实验的结果都复制了点之间距离对曲线的影响以及男性在曲线追踪中的表现优势。所有任务在准确性上至少都与其他任务显著相关。干扰曲线操作的发现为使用变焦镜头策略提供了支持。然而,对男性和女性的发现产生了相互矛盾的结果。最后,排除 SART 表现并不影响曲线追踪和 MRT 表现之间的相关性。讨论强调了曲线追踪和心理旋转中常见的部分处理成分。需要进一步研究以检查策略使用方面的进一步潜在性别差异。(PsycInfo 数据库记录(c)2023 APA,保留所有权利)。