Department of Mathematics & Computer Science, Eindhoven University of Technology, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Department of Neurosurgery, Elisabeth-Tweesteden Hospital, Tilburg, The Netherlands.
J Digit Imaging. 2023 Dec;36(6):2648-2661. doi: 10.1007/s10278-023-00883-0. Epub 2023 Aug 3.
MRI-based tractography is still underexploited and unsuited for routine use in brain tumor surgery due to heterogeneity of methods and functional-anatomical definitions and above all, the lack of a turn-key system. Standardization of methods is therefore desirable, whereby an objective and reliable approach is a prerequisite before the results of any automated procedure can subsequently be validated and used in neurosurgical practice. In this work, we evaluated these preliminary but necessary steps in healthy volunteers. Specifically, we evaluated the robustness and reliability (i.e., test-retest reproducibility) of tractography results of six clinically relevant white matter tracts by using healthy volunteer data (N = 136) from the Human Connectome Project consortium. A deep learning convolutional network-based approach was used for individualized segmentation of regions of interest, combined with an evidence-based tractography protocol and appropriate post-tractography filtering. Robustness was evaluated by estimating the consistency of tractography probability maps, i.e., averaged tractograms in normalized space, through the use of a hold-out cross-validation approach. No major outliers were found, indicating a high robustness of the tractography results. Reliability was evaluated at the individual level. First by examining the overlap of tractograms that resulted from repeatedly processed identical MRI scans (N = 10, 10 iterations) to establish an upper limit of reliability of the pipeline. Second, by examining the overlap for subjects that were scanned twice at different time points (N = 40). Both analyses indicated high reliability, with the second analysis showing a reliability near the upper limit. The robust and reliable subject-specific generation of white matter tracts in healthy subjects holds promise for future validation of our pipeline in a clinical population and subsequent implementation in brain tumor surgery.
基于 MRI 的束流追踪技术由于方法和功能解剖定义的异质性,以及缺乏一站式系统,仍未得到充分利用,不适合常规用于脑肿瘤手术。因此,方法的标准化是可取的,在任何自动化程序的结果随后可以在神经外科实践中得到验证和使用之前,客观和可靠的方法是先决条件。在这项工作中,我们在健康志愿者中评估了这些初步但必要的步骤。具体来说,我们使用人类连接组计划协会的健康志愿者数据(N=136)评估了六个临床相关白质束的束流追踪结果的稳健性和可靠性(即测试-重测可重复性)。使用基于深度学习卷积网络的方法对感兴趣区域进行个体化分割,结合基于证据的束流追踪方案和适当的后束流追踪滤波。通过使用预留交叉验证方法来估计束流追踪概率图(即归一化空间中的平均束流追踪)的一致性,来评估稳健性。未发现主要离群值,表明束流追踪结果具有较高的稳健性。可靠性在个体水平上进行评估。首先,通过检查重复处理相同 MRI 扫描(N=10,10 次迭代)得到的束流追踪的重叠,以确定该管道的可靠性上限。其次,通过检查在不同时间点扫描两次的受试者的重叠(N=40)来检查可靠性。这两种分析都表明了高可靠性,第二次分析显示可靠性接近上限。在健康受试者中,对大脑白质束进行稳健可靠的个体化生成,有望为我们的管道在临床人群中的未来验证以及随后在脑肿瘤手术中的实施铺平道路。