Pio Luca, Wijnen Marc H W A, Giuliani Stefano, Sarnacki Sabine, Davidoff Andrew M, Abdelhafeez Abdelhafeez H
Department of Surgery, MS133, St. Jude Children's Researsch Hospital, Memphis, TN, USA.
Learning Planet Institute, Université de Paris, Paris, France.
Ann Surg Oncol. 2023 Nov;30(12):7789-7798. doi: 10.1245/s10434-023-13953-y. Epub 2023 Aug 5.
Fluorescence-guided surgery (FGS) with indocyanine green (ICG) is increasingly applied in pediatric surgical oncology. However, FGS has been mostly reported in case studies of liver or renal tumors. Applying novel technologies in pediatric surgical oncology is more challenging than in adult surgical oncology due to differences in tumor histology, biology, and fewer cases. No consensus exists on ICG-guided FGS for surgically managing pediatric solid tumors. Therefore, we reviewed the literature and discuss the limitations and prospects of FGS.
Using PRISMA guidelines, we analyzed articles on ICG-guided FGS for childhood solid tumors. Case reports, opinion articles, and narrative reviews were excluded.
Of the 108 articles analyzed, 17 (14 retrospective and 3 prospective) met the inclusion criteria. Most (70.6%) studies used ICG to identify liver tumors, but the timing and dose of ICG administered varied. Intraoperative outcomes, sensitivity and specificity, were reported in 23.5% of studies. Fluorescence-guided liver resections resulted in negative margins in 90-100% of cases; lung metastasis was detected in 33% of the studies. In otolaryngologic malignancies, positive margins without fluorescence signal were reported in 25% of cases. Overall, ICG appeared effective and safe for lymph node sampling and nephron-sparing procedures.
Despite promising results from FGS, ICG use varies across the international pediatric surgical oncology community. Underreported intraoperative imaging outcomes and the diversity and rarity of childhood solid tumors hinder conclusive scientific evidence supporting adoption of ICG in pediatric surgical oncology. Further international collaborations are needed to study the applications and limitations of ICG in pediatric surgical oncology.
使用吲哚菁绿(ICG)的荧光引导手术(FGS)在小儿外科肿瘤学中的应用越来越广泛。然而,FGS大多报道于肝脏或肾脏肿瘤的病例研究中。由于肿瘤组织学、生物学方面的差异以及病例较少,在小儿外科肿瘤学中应用新技术比在成人外科肿瘤学中更具挑战性。对于ICG引导的FGS用于手术治疗小儿实体瘤,目前尚无共识。因此,我们回顾了相关文献并讨论了FGS的局限性和前景。
我们按照PRISMA指南,分析了关于ICG引导的FGS用于儿童实体瘤的文章。排除了病例报告、观点文章和叙述性综述。
在分析的108篇文章中,有17篇(14篇回顾性研究和3篇前瞻性研究)符合纳入标准。大多数(70.6%)研究使用ICG来识别肝脏肿瘤,但ICG的给药时间和剂量各不相同。23.5%的研究报告了术中结果、敏感性和特异性。荧光引导下的肝切除术在90%-100%的病例中实现了切缘阴性;33%的研究中检测到了肺转移。在耳鼻喉科恶性肿瘤中,25%的病例报告了无荧光信号的阳性切缘。总体而言,ICG在淋巴结取样和保留肾单位手术中似乎是有效且安全的。
尽管FGS取得了令人鼓舞的结果,但ICG在国际小儿外科肿瘤学界的使用情况各不相同。术中成像结果报告不足以及儿童实体瘤的多样性和罕见性阻碍了支持在小儿外科肿瘤学中采用ICG的确凿科学证据的形成。需要进一步开展国际合作来研究ICG在小儿外科肿瘤学中的应用和局限性。