Döllinger Lillian, Högman Lennart Björn, Laukka Petri, Bänziger Tanja, Makower Irena, Fischer Håkan, Hau Stephan
Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.
Department of Psychology and Social Work, Mid Sweden University, Östersund, Sweden.
Front Psychol. 2023 Jul 20;14:1188634. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1188634. eCollection 2023.
Psychotherapists' emotional and empathic competencies have a positive influence on psychotherapy outcome and alliance. However, it is doubtful whether psychotherapy education in itself leads to improvements in trainee psychotherapists' emotion recognition accuracy (ERA), which is an essential part of these competencies.
In a randomized, controlled, double-blind study ( = 68), we trained trainee psychotherapists (57% psychodynamic therapy and 43% cognitive behavioral therapy) to detect non-verbal emotional expressions in others using standardized computerized trainings - one for multimodal emotion recognition accuracy and one for micro expression recognition accuracy - and compared their results to an active control group one week after the training ( = 60) and at the one-year follow up ( = 55). The participants trained once weekly during a three-week period. As outcome measures, we used a multimodal emotion recognition accuracy task, a micro expression recognition accuracy task and an emotion recognition accuracy task for verbal and non-verbal (combined) emotional expressions in medical settings.
The results of mixed multilevel analyses suggest that the multimodal emotion recognition accuracy training led to significantly steeper increases than the other two conditions from pretest to the posttest one week after the last training session. When comparing the pretest to follow-up differences in slopes, the superiority of the multimodal training group was still detectable in the unimodal audio modality and the unimodal video modality (in comparison to the control training group), but not when considering the multimodal audio-video modality or the total score of the multimodal emotion recognition accuracy measure. The micro expression training group showed a significantly steeper change trajectory from pretest to posttest compared to the control training group, but not compared to the multimodal training group. However, the effect vanished again until the one-year follow-up. There were no differences in change trajectories for the outcome measure about emotion recognition accuracy in medical settings.
We conclude that trainee psychotherapists' emotion recognition accuracy can be effectively trained, especially multimodal emotion recognition accuracy, and suggest that the changes in unimodal emotion recognition accuracy (audio-only and video-only) are long-lasting. Implications of these findings for the psychotherapy education are discussed.
心理治疗师的情感和共情能力对心理治疗的效果和联盟有着积极影响。然而,心理治疗教育本身是否能提高实习心理治疗师的情绪识别准确性(ERA)令人怀疑,而情绪识别准确性是这些能力的重要组成部分。
在一项随机、对照、双盲研究(n = 68)中,我们使用标准化的计算机化训练,对实习心理治疗师(57%为心理动力疗法,43%为认知行为疗法)进行培训,以检测他人的非语言情感表达——一种用于多模态情绪识别准确性,另一种用于微表情识别准确性——并将他们的结果与一个积极对照组在训练后一周(n = 60)和一年随访时(n = 55)的结果进行比较。参与者在为期三周的时间里每周训练一次。作为结果指标,我们使用了一项多模态情绪识别准确性任务、一项微表情识别准确性任务以及一项针对医疗环境中言语和非言语(综合)情感表达的情绪识别准确性任务。
混合多层次分析的结果表明,从最后一次训练课程后的预测试到一周后的后测试,多模态情绪识别准确性训练导致的提升比其他两种情况显著更大。当比较预测试到随访时斜率的差异时,多模态训练组的优势在单模态音频模式和单模态视频模式中仍然可以检测到(与对照训练组相比),但在考虑多模态音频 - 视频模式或多模态情绪识别准确性测量的总分时则不然。与对照训练组相比,微表情训练组从预测试到后测试显示出显著更大的变化轨迹,但与多模态训练组相比则不然。然而,这种效果在一年随访时再次消失。在医疗环境中情绪识别准确性的结果指标的变化轨迹上没有差异。
我们得出结论,实习心理治疗师的情绪识别准确性,尤其是多模态情绪识别准确性,可以得到有效训练,并表明单模态情绪识别准确性(仅音频和仅视频)的变化是持久的。讨论了这些发现对心理治疗教育的意义。