Waters D D, Crean P A, Roy D, Théroux P
Can J Cardiol. 1986 Jul;Suppl A:173A-179A.
We compared the sensitivity of three commonly used provocative tests, exercise, ergonovine and the cold pressor test, in a series of 34 hospitalized patients with well-documented, active variant angina. All tests were performed off medication at the same time of day, usually on 3 consecutive days. Angina was provoked by ergonovine in all 34 patients, by exercise in 17 and by the cold pressor test in only 5 (p less than 0.005). ST elevation developed during the ergonovine test in 32 (94%), during exercise in 10 (29%) and during the cold pressor test in only 3 (9%). With ergonovine one patient had ST depression only and one had no ECG changes. During the cold pressor test two patients had pseudonormalization of abnormally negative T waves and 29 had no ECG changes. Exercise induced T wave pseudonormalization in 4 patients, ST depression in 9 others and no ECG changes in 11. Thus, in patients with active variant angina, the sensitivity of the cold pressor test and exercise are too low to be useful clinically. Other studies suggest that the sensitivity of hyperventilation or provoked alkalosis is higher, but not as high as ergonovine administration. In patients who have become asymptomatic, either with treatment or spontaneously, the sensitivity of all tests decreases markedly. If such patients no longer have coronary spasm, the test is not a 'false negative' but a 'true negative'. Deaths have been reported following ergonovine administration and for this reason the test is not universally accepted.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
我们在34例有充分记录的活动性变异型心绞痛住院患者中,比较了三种常用激发试验(运动、麦角新碱和冷加压试验)的敏感性。所有试验均在停药状态下于一天中的同一时间进行,通常连续进行3天。34例患者中,麦角新碱诱发心绞痛34例,运动诱发17例,冷加压试验仅诱发5例(P<0.005)。麦角新碱试验期间32例(94%)出现ST段抬高,运动试验期间10例(29%)出现,冷加压试验期间仅3例(9%)出现。麦角新碱试验中有1例仅出现ST段压低,1例心电图无改变。冷加压试验中有2例异常倒置T波假性正常化,29例心电图无改变。运动试验诱发4例T波假性正常化,9例ST段压低,11例心电图无改变。因此,在活动性变异型心绞痛患者中,冷加压试验和运动试验的敏感性过低,临床应用价值不大。其他研究表明,过度通气或诱发碱中毒试验的敏感性较高,但不如麦角新碱试验。在经治疗或自行无症状的患者中,所有试验的敏感性均显著降低。如果此类患者不再有冠状动脉痉挛,该试验并非“假阴性”而是“真阴性”。已有麦角新碱给药后死亡的报道,因此该试验未被普遍接受。(摘要截短于250字)