School of Social Work, East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina, US.
Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel School of Applied Social Sciences, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, US.
J Evid Based Soc Work (2019). 2023 Nov 2;20(6):1004-1025. doi: 10.1080/26408066.2023.2245819. Epub 2023 Aug 13.
This study evaluated effectiveness of the Neurosequential Model of Therapeutics (NMT) with adoptive families who received post adoption services in Tennessee.
Researchers obtained a sample of 552 families who received post adoption services in the U.S. state of Tennessee. Most families (77%) had adopted children through public child welfare services. A quasi-experimental design examined wellbeing outcomes for an NMT group ( = 319) versus a services-as-usual (SAU) group ( = 233) in intent-to-treat analyses. Then, the SAU group was contrasted to an NMT subgroup that had high adherence to the NMT model ( = 109) in an analysis of treatment-on-the-treated.
Intent-to-treat models indicated no differences on outcomes between the NMT and SAU groups. However, the results of treatment-on-the-treated analyses showed slightly greater reduction on the Behavior Problems Index over time for the NMT with high adherence group as compared to SAU.
Adoptive families may face challenges that could be addressed through developmentally sensitive, trauma-informed services, such as NMT. The results of this study suggest that the NMT might benefit adoptive families if greater attention is paid to implementation adherence, or fidelity.
本研究评估了神经序贯治疗模式(NMT)在田纳西州接受收养后服务的收养家庭中的有效性。
研究人员从美国田纳西州获得了接受收养后服务的 552 个家庭的样本。大多数家庭(77%)通过公共儿童福利服务收养了孩子。准实验设计检查了 NMT 组( = 319)与服务即常规(SAU)组( = 233)在意向治疗分析中的健康结果。然后,在治疗已处理的分析中,将 SAU 组与对 NMT 模型具有高依从性的 NMT 亚组( = 109)进行对比。
意向治疗模型表明,NMT 和 SAU 组之间在结果上没有差异。然而,治疗已处理的分析结果表明,与 SAU 相比,高依从性的 NMT 组随着时间的推移,行为问题指数的减少略大。
收养家庭可能面临挑战,这些挑战可以通过发展敏感、创伤知情的服务来解决,例如 NMT。本研究的结果表明,如果更加关注实施依从性或保真度,NMT 可能会使收养家庭受益。