Agarwal Prerna, Rawekar Alka
Datta Meghe Institute of Medical Sciences.
MedEdPublish (2016). 2020 Feb 12;8:103. doi: 10.15694/mep.2019.000103.2. eCollection 2019.
This article was migrated. The article was marked as recommended. The escalating problem of unprofessionalism calls for teaching medical professionalism in a manner that should lead to deeper learning. Early clinical exposure (ECE) to an Intensive Care Unit (ICU) presents the issues pertaining to medical professionalism to the students in a more explicit and emotionally challenging manner. And reflection note writing evokes the critical process of thought and analysis required for learning. We conducted the present study to sensitize the pre-clinical students towards medical professionalism using these two tools, ECE and Reflection. Two hundred students of 1 MBBS were given an Objective Structured Clinical Examinations (OSCE). The students were then taken for ECE to an ICU. There, the students observed different ongoing activities and critical patients, a doctor discussed some cases with them, and they also interacted with the relatives of patients admitted in the ICU. Thereafter, students wrote a 'reflection' note describing what did you see? so what? and now what? Students were again given an OSCE, similar to the one given before the ECE, for assessing any change in their professional behaviour.Analysis of reflection notes was done thematically and of OSCE scores using paired t-test (p<0.05). The analysis of reflection notes revealed the budding of different elements of professionalism among the students. Post-visit OSCE scores also showed significant improvement. Incorporation of reflection note writing along with ECE is helpful in laying the foundation of medical professionalism among pre-clinical students.
本文已迁移。该文章被标记为推荐文章。日益严重的不专业问题要求以能促进深入学习的方式来教授医学专业精神。早期临床接触(ECE)重症监护病房(ICU)能以更明确且在情感上更具挑战性的方式向学生呈现与医学专业精神相关的问题。而撰写反思笔记能引发学习所需的批判性思考和分析过程。我们开展本研究,旨在使用早期临床接触(ECE)和反思这两种工具,使临床前学生对医学专业精神更敏感。100名医学学士一年级学生接受了客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)。然后,这些学生被带去重症监护病房进行早期临床接触(ECE)。在那里,学生观察了不同的正在进行的活动和重症患者,一名医生与他们讨论了一些病例,他们还与重症监护病房收治患者的亲属进行了互动。之后,学生撰写了一篇“反思”笔记,描述“你看到了什么?那又怎样?现在该怎么做?”。学生再次接受了与早期临床接触(ECE)之前类似的客观结构化临床考试(OSCE),以评估他们专业行为的任何变化。对反思笔记进行了主题分析,对客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)分数使用配对t检验(p<0.05)进行分析。对反思笔记的分析揭示了学生中专业精神不同要素的萌芽。访后客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)分数也显示出显著提高。将反思笔记撰写与早期临床接触(ECE)相结合有助于在临床前学生中奠定医学专业精神的基础。