Atwal Anita, Sriram Vimal, McKay Elizabeth A
London South Banking University, School of Allied and Community Health, London, UK.
University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust, Bristol, UK.
J Multidiscip Healthc. 2023 Aug 9;16:2251-2259. doi: 10.2147/JMDH.S413085. eCollection 2023.
Diversity, equality and belonging are important aspects within Allied Health Professional (AHP) groups. Mentoring is considered as a solution to improve career progression. To date, there is no consensus on what good mentoring looks like and whether current models are fit for purpose for Black and Minoritised Ethnicity AHPs.
Scoping review to understand mentoring among Black and Minoritised Ethnicity (BME) AHPs through searches in four electronic databases using pre-defined criteria.
From 1440 studies screened, 2 studies were included in this review that researched mentoring for BME AHPs in a health and/or social care setting. Themes that emerged from the literature were related to access and amount of mentoring for BME AHPs, psychosocial mentoring may influence cross-race mentorship outcomes and organisational issues related to workforce pressures and management support. There is uncertainty around the importance of same race relationships in mentoring but there is some evidence that within cross-race mentoring this could influence outcomes.
It is unknown if mentoring enables career success in BME AHPs. There is emerging evidence on the importance of psychosocial mentoring within cross-race relationships. Careful reflection and further research is needed on how current mentoring models work and ensure fair access to mentorship and support for BME AHPs.
多样性、平等和归属感是联合健康专业人员(AHP)群体中的重要方面。指导被视为促进职业发展的一种解决方案。迄今为止,对于良好的指导应是什么样以及当前模式是否适合黑人和少数族裔AHP的目的,尚无共识。
通过在四个电子数据库中按照预定义标准进行检索,进行范围综述以了解黑人和少数族裔(BME)AHP中的指导情况。
在筛选的1440项研究中,本综述纳入了2项研究,这些研究在健康和/或社会护理环境中对BME AHP的指导进行了研究。文献中出现的主题与BME AHP获得指导的机会和指导的数量、心理社会指导可能影响跨种族指导结果以及与劳动力压力和管理支持相关的组织问题有关。关于同种族关系在指导中的重要性存在不确定性,但有一些证据表明,在跨种族指导中,这可能会影响结果。
尚不清楚指导是否能使BME AHP取得职业成功。关于跨种族关系中心理社会指导的重要性,有新的证据出现。需要对当前的指导模式如何运作进行仔细反思和进一步研究,并确保BME AHP能够公平地获得指导和支持。