Poynard T, Mignon M, Accary J P, Bonfils S
Gastroenterol Clin Biol. 1986 Jun-Jul;10(6-7):492-6.
From 1974 to 1981, 55 patients, 18 with Zollinger-Ellison syndrome (ZES) histologically confirmed and 37 patients with duodenal ulcer (DU) without pylorostenosis were followed for a minimal period of 5 years. The diagnostic values of a) basal acid output (BAO mEq/h); b) 60 min acid output after secretin infusion, 3 CU-GIH/kg, (MAO-SE mEq/h); c) basal serum gastrin (BSG pg/ml: mean of 4 gastrin determinations) and d) serum gastrin after secretin (SG-SE pg/ml: mean of 4 gastrin determinations during secretin infusion) were calculated. Cut off point values of 100 p. 100 specificity (i. e. no DU patient reached these values) with a positive predictive value of 100 p. 100 (i. e. probability for gastrinoma when this cut off point was attained) were BAO greater than 26 mEq/h, MAO-SE greater than 18 mEq/h, BSG greater than 221 pg/ml, SG-SE greater than 186 pg/ml. The sensitivities of these parameters (i. e. percent of ZES which reached the given cut off point) were respectively (p. 100): 39, 78, 72 and 94. Ranking these parameters according to their own discriminative value expressed by R2 (square correlation coefficient) gave SG-SE, R2 = 0.559; BSG, R2 = 0.508; MAO-SE, R2 = 0.456; BAO, R2 = 0.414. The most discriminative association of 2 variables was SG-SE and MAO-SE (R2 = 0.650). Association of SG-SE, MAO-SE and BAO or BSG (or BAO and BSG) did not increase significantly the discrimination between ZES and DU (R2 = 0.672).
1974年至1981年,对55例患者进行了至少5年的随访,其中18例经组织学确诊为卓-艾综合征(ZES),37例为无幽门狭窄的十二指肠溃疡(DU)患者。计算了以下各项的诊断价值:a)基础胃酸分泌量(BAO,mEq/h);b)静脉注射促胰液素(3 CU - GIH/kg)后60分钟胃酸分泌量(MAO - SE,mEq/h);c)基础血清胃泌素(BSG,pg/ml:4次胃泌素测定结果的平均值);d)促胰液素注射后血清胃泌素(SG - SE,pg/ml:促胰液素注射期间4次胃泌素测定结果的平均值)。截断点值为:BAO大于26 mEq/h、MAO - SE大于18 mEq/h、BSG大于221 pg/ml、SG - SE大于186 pg/ml时,特异性为100%(即无DU患者达到这些值),阳性预测值为100%(即达到该截断点时患胃泌素瘤的概率)。这些参数的敏感度(即达到给定截断点的ZES患者百分比,%)分别为:39、78、72和94。根据由R2(平方相关系数)表示的自身判别值对这些参数进行排序,结果为:SG - SE,R2 = 0.559;BSG,R2 = 0.508;MAO - SE,R2 = 0.456;BAO,R2 = 0.414。两个变量中最具判别力的组合是SG - SE和MAO - SE(R2 = 0.650)。SG - SE、MAO - SE与BAO或BSG(或BAO和BSG)的组合并没有显著增加ZES和DU之间的判别力(R2 = 0.672)。