Faculty of Forestry, Universitas Sumatera Utara, Medan, 20155, Indonesia.
Faculty of Agriculture, Universitas Sumatera Utara, Medan, 20155, Indonesia.
F1000Res. 2024 Jan 4;11:627. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.114592.2. eCollection 2022.
Noise has the potential to affect the comfort and health of workers. The objective of this research was to determines the effects of noise on the concentration levels of both chainsaw operators and harvesting workers in industrial forest plantation, North Sumatra, Indonesia.
This experimental study included 20 respondents which consisted of 10 chainsaw operators/helpers and 10 harvesting workers. All respondents were exposed to the sound of a chainsaw in three different conditions (idle, half gas and racing conditions) with and without personal protective equipment (PPEs: earmuffs, ear plugs and without PPE). The sound intensity produced by the chainsaw and the noise received by the respondents were measured using a sound level meter. Respondents' perception toward noise was recorded using a Likert scale. Respondents' concentration level was assessed by giving 25 math-questions to be answered within 10 minutes. Wilcoxon sign rank test was used to analysed paired data.
The average sound intensity received by respondents' left and right ears were lower than the average sound intensity produced by the chainsaw. The use of earmuffs leads to better perception towards noise when compared with the use of earplugs and the absence of any PPE. Based on Wilcoxon test, the noise did not have significant impact on the concentration level of chainsaw operators, whilst the contrary result is true for harvesting workers.
The research indicated that although the noise produced by the chainsaw was considered noisy for both chainsaw operators and harvesting workers, it did not have a significant effect on the concentration level of chainsaw operators and only affected the harvesting workers. Therefore, given that the harvesting workers were still affected by the noise, noise control measures are still needed to ensure occupational safety and health for the workers.
噪声有可能影响工人的舒适度和健康。本研究旨在确定在印度尼西亚北苏门答腊的工业人工林种植园中,噪声对链锯操作人员和采伐工人注意力集中水平的影响。
本实验研究包括 20 名受访者,其中包括 10 名链锯操作人员/助手和 10 名采伐工人。所有受访者均在三种不同条件(空转、半油门和赛车条件)下接触链锯声,同时佩戴和不佩戴个人防护设备(耳塞、耳罩和不佩戴 PPE)。使用声级计测量链锯产生的声强和受访者接收到的噪声。使用李克特量表记录受访者对噪声的感知。通过给受访者 25 道数学题,要求他们在 10 分钟内回答,评估受访者的注意力水平。采用 Wilcoxon 符号秩检验对配对数据进行分析。
受访者左右耳接收到的平均声强均低于链锯产生的平均声强。与使用耳塞相比,使用耳罩可使受访者对噪声的感知更好,而不佩戴任何 PPE 的情况下感知最差。根据 Wilcoxon 检验,噪声对链锯操作人员的注意力水平没有显著影响,而对采伐工人的注意力水平则有相反的影响。
研究表明,尽管链锯产生的噪声被认为对链锯操作人员和采伐工人都很嘈杂,但它并没有显著影响链锯操作人员的注意力水平,而只影响了采伐工人。因此,鉴于采伐工人仍受到噪声的影响,仍需要采取噪声控制措施,以确保工人的职业安全和健康。