School of Letters, Osaka University, Toyonaka, Japan.
Italian School of East Asian Studies, Kyoto, Japan.
PLoS One. 2023 Aug 18;18(8):e0289748. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0289748. eCollection 2023.
This paper analyzes the collapse of the Qing dynasty (1644-1912) through the lens of the Structural Demographic Theory (SDT), a general framework for understanding the drivers of socio-political instability in state-level societies. Although a number of competing ideas for the collapse have been proposed, none provide a comprehensive explanation that incorporates the interaction of all the multiple drivers involved. We argue that the four-fold population explosion peaking in the 19th century, the growing competition for a stagnant number of elite positions, and increasing state fiscal stress combined to produce an increasingly disgruntled populace and elite, leading to significant internal rebellions. We find that while neither the ecological disasters nor the foreign incursions during the 19th century were sufficient on their own to bring down the Qing, when coupled with the rising internal socio-political stresses, they produced a rapid succession of triggering events that culminated in the Qing collapse.
本文通过结构人口理论(SDT)分析了清朝(1644-1912 年)的崩溃,SDT 是一种理解国家层面社会中社会政治不稳定驱动因素的通用框架。尽管已经提出了许多关于崩溃的竞争理论,但没有一个提供了全面的解释,将所有涉及的多个驱动因素的相互作用都包含在内。我们认为,19 世纪达到峰值的四倍人口爆炸、争夺数量停滞不前的精英职位的竞争日益激烈以及国家财政压力的不断增加,共同导致了日益不满的民众和精英阶层的出现,从而引发了重大的内部叛乱。我们发现,虽然 19 世纪的生态灾难和外来入侵本身都不足以推翻清朝,但当与不断上升的内部社会政治压力结合在一起时,它们产生了一系列触发事件,最终导致了清朝的崩溃。