Department of Cardiology, Research, Hospital Rijnstate, Arnhem, The Netherlands
Department of Cardiology, Research, Hospital Rijnstate, Arnhem, The Netherlands.
BMJ Open. 2023 Aug 18;13(8):e072655. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-072655.
To investigate the underprescription of oral anticoagulation (OAC) in individual atrial fibrillation (AF) patients in primary care.
Screening of patient records in 39 participating general practitioners (GPs) across the Netherlands.
We screened 101 207 patient records identifying 2375 non-valvular AF patients.
Using electronic patient files, we were able to screen the entire GP population for AF, CHADS-VASc stroke risk scores, and the use of guidelines recommended OAC prescription. In case of a deviation from guidelines recommended OAC prescription, we checked the electronic patient file for any documented reason. Additionally, 6 weeks following the screening, we asked all GPs to provide information on any actions taken for the underprescribed patients.
We found a mean CHADS-VASc score of 3.2. OAC prescription consisted of direct OAC in 1342/1984 (68%) and vitamin K-antagonists in the remainder of patients. OAC underprescription was present in 93/944 (9.9%) females and 101/1374 (9.7%) in males, respectively. In 111/146 (76.0%) of the underprescribed AF patients, no reason to withhold OAC was reported. Reported reasons to withhold OAC were patient refusal (n=10), cardiologist advice (n=7) and high risk of bleeding (n=7). Data regarding actions following the identification of OAC underprescription were available for 92/194 (47%) of the OAC underprescribed cases. After consultation OAC was initiated in 9/92 (10%) only.
In this large Dutch study among GPs, we observed 9.8% underprescription of OAC in AF patients. In 76% of the AF patients lacking a prescription for OAC, no documentation for deviating from the guidelines was found. Only in a minority of cases detection of OAC underprescription lead to OAC initiation.
调查初级保健中个别房颤(AF)患者口服抗凝剂(OAC)处方不足的情况。
在荷兰的 39 名全科医生(GP)中筛选患者病历。
我们筛选了 101207 名患者的病历,确定了 2375 名非瓣膜性房颤患者。
使用电子病历,我们能够筛选整个 GP 人群的 AF、CHADS-VASc 中风风险评分和指南推荐的 OAC 处方使用情况。如果 OAC 处方偏离指南推荐,我们会检查电子病历中是否有任何记录的原因。此外,在筛选后 6 周,我们要求所有 GP 提供有关为处方不足的患者采取的任何行动的信息。
我们发现平均 CHADS-VASc 评分为 3.2。OAC 处方包括直接 OAC 1342/1984 例(68%)和维生素 K 拮抗剂在其余患者中。女性 OAC 处方不足 93/944(9.9%),男性 OAC 处方不足 101/1374(9.7%)。在 146 例(76.0%) OAC 处方不足的 AF 患者中,没有报告拒绝 OAC 的原因。拒绝 OAC 的报告原因包括患者拒绝(n=10)、心脏病专家建议(n=7)和高出血风险(n=7)。在 92/194(47%)例 OAC 处方不足的病例中,有关于确定 OAC 处方不足后采取的行动的数据。在 9/92(10%)例中,仅在咨询后开始 OAC。
在这项针对 GP 的大型荷兰研究中,我们观察到 AF 患者 OAC 处方不足的比例为 9.8%。在缺乏 OAC 处方的 AF 患者中,76%的患者没有发现偏离指南的文件。只有在少数情况下,检测到 OAC 处方不足会导致 OAC 开始。