Population Health Sciences Institute, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
St Oswald's Hospice, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Palliat Med. 2023 Oct;37(9):1447-1460. doi: 10.1177/02692163231188156. Epub 2023 Aug 23.
People of African and Caribbean descent experienced disproportionately high mortality from COVID-19 and have poor access to palliative care.
To explore palliative care experiences of people of African and Caribbean descent during and immediately prior to the pandemic.
Qualitative interview study with thematic analysis. Refinement of themes/recommendations in consultation with an expert patient and public advisory group.
SETTING/PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-six bereaved relatives and 13 health/social care professionals (cared for people of African and Caribbean descent) from throughout England, recruited using social media, community networks and direct advertising to over 150 organisations.
Three themes were identified: Participants did not see themselves reflected in the palliative care services and did not expect their needs to be understood. Mistrust of the healthcare system and perceptions of racism were common and led to anticipation of inequitable care. Relatives and professionals reported a lack of cultural and religious sensitivity in healthcare. Assumptions were made based on ethnicity, and services not offered to all. Professionals felt they lacked the knowledge to provide care to diverse communities, but were reluctant to ask, due to fear of making mistakes. Inequitable access to services was exacerbated by, but not unique to, the pandemic. Participants recommended raising awareness of palliative services, building professional competence in culturally-sensitive care, and greater ethnic diversity within services.
Person-centred, culturally-competent palliative care is not the norm for people of African and Caribbean descent. Expectations of inequitable care are widespread. Sustained action on multiple fronts is needed.
非洲裔和加勒比裔人群在 COVID-19 中的死亡率不成比例地高,并且获得姑息治疗的机会很差。
探讨大流行期间和之前非洲裔和加勒比裔人群的姑息治疗体验。
定性访谈研究,采用主题分析。与专家患者和公众咨询小组协商,对主题/建议进行细化。
地点/参与者:来自英格兰各地的 26 名死者亲属和 13 名卫生/社会保健专业人员(照顾非洲和加勒比裔人群),通过社交媒体、社区网络和直接向 150 多个组织进行宣传招募。
确定了三个主题:参与者在姑息治疗服务中看不到自己的影子,也不期望自己的需求得到理解。对医疗保健系统的不信任和对种族主义的看法很常见,导致对不平等护理的预期。亲属和专业人员报告说,医疗保健缺乏文化和宗教敏感性。根据族裔做出假设,并且并非所有服务都提供给所有人。专业人员认为他们缺乏为不同社区提供护理的知识,但由于害怕犯错,他们不愿意询问。服务的不平等获取不仅因大流行而加剧。参与者建议提高对姑息治疗服务的认识,提高文化敏感性护理方面的专业能力,并在服务中增加种族多样性。
以患者为中心、文化上有能力的姑息治疗并不是非洲裔和加勒比裔人群的常态。对不平等护理的期望普遍存在。需要在多个方面采取持续行动。