Groenendaal Huybert, Costard Solenne, Ballard Reid, Bienhoff Stephen, Challen Diana C, Dominguez Brandon J, Kern Douglas R, Miller Dan, Noordergraaf Jeske, Rudenko Larisa, Schuurman Henk-Jan, Spizzo Tom, Sturos Matthew, Zollers Bill, Fishman Jay A
EpiX Analytics, LLC, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA.
Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA.
Xenotransplantation. 2023 Sep-Oct;30(5):e12815. doi: 10.1111/xen.12815. Epub 2023 Aug 24.
Xenotransplantation has the potential to address shortages of organs available for clinical transplantation, but concerns exist regarding potential risks posed by porcine microorganisms and parasites (MP) to the health of human recipients. In this study, a risk-based framework was developed, and expert opinion was elicited to evaluate porcine MP based on swine exposure and risk to human health. Experts identified 255 MP to include in the risk assessment. These were rated by experts for five criteria regarding potential swine exposure in the USA and human health risks. MP were subsequently categorized into three risk mitigation groups according to pre-defined rules: disqualifying porcine MP (due to their pathogenic potential, n = 130); non-disqualifying porcine MP (still relevant to consider for biosecurity or monitoring efforts, n = 40); and alert/watch list (not reported in the USA or MP not in swine, n = 85). Most disqualifying (n = 126) and non-disqualifying (n = 36) porcine MP can effectively be eliminated with high biosecurity programs. This approach supports surveillance and risk mitigation strategies for porcine MP in swine produced for xenotransplantation, such as documentation of freedom from porcine MP, or use of porcine MP screening, monitoring, or elimination options. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first effort to comprehensively identify all relevant porcine MP systematically and transparently evaluate the risk of infection of both donor animals and immunosuppressed human recipients, and the potential health impacts for immunosuppressed human recipients from infected xenotransplantation products from pigs.
异种移植有潜力解决临床移植可用器官短缺的问题,但人们担心猪的微生物和寄生虫(MP)对人类受者健康构成的潜在风险。在本研究中,开发了一个基于风险的框架,并征求专家意见,以根据猪的接触情况和对人类健康的风险评估猪MP。专家们确定了255种MP纳入风险评估。根据关于在美国猪的潜在接触情况和人类健康风险的五个标准,专家们对这些MP进行了评级。随后,根据预先定义的规则,MP被分为三个风险缓解组:不合格猪MP(因其致病潜力,n = 130);非不合格猪MP(仍与生物安全或监测工作相关,n = 40);以及警示/观察清单(在美国未报告或不在猪体内的MP,n = 85)。大多数不合格(n = 126)和非不合格(n = 36)猪MP可通过高生物安全计划有效消除。这种方法支持对用于异种移植的猪的猪MP进行监测和风险缓解策略,例如记录猪MP的不存在情况,或使用猪MP筛查、监测或消除选项。据作者所知,这是首次全面系统地识别所有相关猪MP,并透明地评估供体动物和免疫抑制人类受者的感染风险,以及免疫抑制人类受者因感染猪的异种移植产品而可能产生的健康影响。