Vettori Giulia, Incognito Oriana, Bigozzi Lucia, Pinto Giuliana
Department of Education, Languages, Intercultures, Literatures and Psychology, University of Florence, Florence, Italy.
Front Psychol. 2023 Aug 10;14:1121505. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1121505. eCollection 2023.
This study was conducted on a population of primary school children including bilingual language minority (BLM) children with L2-Italian and a variety of languages as L1 (e.g., Chinese, Albanian, Latin), and Italian-speaking monolingual children. The variety of languages ecologically reflects the nowadays composition of classes in the Italian school system. The aims were to investigate in both linguistic groups: (1) the developmental patterns of lexical, reading and spelling skills; (2) the pattern of predictive relations between lexical, reading and spelling skills. 159 primary school children from Grade 2 to Grade 5 participated in the study: BLM ( = 80) and monolingual ( = 79) children aged between 7 and 11 years. Each participant completed a vocabulary task (lexical skills), a text reading task (reading accuracy and reading speed) and a text dictation task (orthographic errors). ANOVA statistics showed the comparison of patterns between monolingual and BLM children in lexical, reading, and writing skills. Results show lower performances in lexical, reading and spelling skills in BLM children learning Italian as a second language compared to monolingual peers. Second, partial correlations performed separately for monolinguals and BLM with lexical ability as a control variable, illustrated that all variables correlated with each other in both groups. This result provides the option of performing hierarchical regressions. Finally, hierarchical regression analyses showed that the pattern of predictive relations between lexical, reading and spelling skills is the same across language groups, with the key role of orthographic accuracy as the pivotal process around which reading and lexical skills are built.
本研究以一群小学生为对象,其中包括以意大利语为第二语言、母语为多种语言(如中文、阿尔巴尼亚语、拉丁语)的双语少数族裔(BLM)儿童,以及说意大利语的单语儿童。语言的多样性从生态学角度反映了意大利学校系统中班级目前的构成情况。研究目的是在两个语言群体中调查:(1)词汇、阅读和拼写技能的发展模式;(2)词汇、阅读和拼写技能之间的预测关系模式。159名二至五年级的小学生参与了该研究:年龄在7至11岁之间的BLM儿童(n = 80)和单语儿童(n = 79)。每位参与者完成了一项词汇任务(词汇技能)、一项文本阅读任务(阅读准确性和阅读速度)以及一项文本听写任务(拼写错误)。方差分析统计显示了单语儿童和BLM儿童在词汇、阅读和写作技能方面模式的比较。结果表明,与单语同龄人相比,将意大利语作为第二语言学习的BLM儿童在词汇、阅读和拼写技能方面表现较差。其次,以词汇能力作为控制变量,分别对单语儿童和BLM儿童进行偏相关分析,结果表明两组中的所有变量都相互关联。这一结果为进行分层回归分析提供了可能。最后,分层回归分析表明,词汇、阅读和拼写技能之间的预测关系模式在不同语言群体中是相同的,拼写准确性作为关键过程起着核心作用,阅读和词汇技能围绕该核心构建。