Bonifacci Paola, Ferrara Ida Carmen, Pedrinazzi Jessica, Terracina Francesco, Palladino Paola
Department of Psychology, University of Bologna, 40126 Bologna, Italy.
Department of Brain and Behavioral Sciences, University of Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
Brain Sci. 2022 Apr 27;12(5):563. doi: 10.3390/brainsci12050563.
Bilingualism and socio-economic status (SES) differentially affect linguistic and cognitive development. However, less evidence has been collected regarding their impact on literacy trajectories. The present longitudinal study evaluated the literacy development of language minority bilingual children (LMBC) and monolingual peers with different SES. A group of LMBC with low-SES ( = 18) and monolingual peers with low ( = 18) or high ( = 14) SES were followed from 2nd to 5th grade through a set of tasks assessing decoding (words, nonwords, passage), reading, and listening comprehension, and spelling skills. The results showed that all groups achieved better performances over time in all measures, except listening comprehension. However, low-SES LMBC underperformed in spelling tasks compared to the monolingual groups. In reading comprehension, there was a time*group interaction that showed how low-SES LMBC reached similar performances of low-SES monolinguals in fifth grade, but both groups underperformed compared to the high SES monolingual group. The discussion is focused on the need for research and educational settings to consider the differential impact of bilingualism and SES. Bilingualism seems to be associated with a longer time in developing adequate spelling skills, whereas SES was the primary underpinning of the reading comprehension gap over time.
双语能力和社会经济地位(SES)对语言和认知发展的影响存在差异。然而,关于它们对读写能力发展轨迹的影响,所收集的证据较少。本纵向研究评估了不同SES的语言少数群体双语儿童(LMBC)和单语同龄人在读写能力方面的发展情况。一组低SES的LMBC(n = 18)以及低SES(n = 18)或高SES(n = 14)的单语同龄人从二年级到五年级接受了一系列评估解码(单词、非单词、篇章)、阅读和听力理解以及拼写技能的任务。结果表明,除听力理解外,所有组在所有测量指标上随着时间推移都取得了更好的成绩。然而,与单语组相比,低SES的LMBC在拼写任务中表现较差。在阅读理解方面,存在时间*组交互作用,表明低SES的LMBC在五年级时达到了与低SES单语者相似的成绩,但与高SES单语组相比,两组表现均较差。讨论集中在研究和教育环境需要考虑双语能力和SES的差异影响。双语能力似乎与发展足够的拼写技能所需的更长时间相关,而SES是随着时间推移阅读理解差距的主要支撑因素。