University of California, San Francisco School of Medicine, San Francisco, California, U.S.A.
Department of Ophthalmology, University of California, San Francisco School of Medicine, San Francisco, California, U.S.A.
Ophthalmic Plast Reconstr Surg. 2024;40(1):75-87. doi: 10.1097/IOP.0000000000002510. Epub 2023 Sep 1.
To evaluate and compare eye and face trauma in mixed martial arts (MMA) and boxing.
Retrospective cohort study.
Data from boxing and MMA competitions were extracted from the Nevada Athletic Commission (NAC) between 2000 and 2020. Details of competitions, contestants, outcomes, and injuries were extracted.
In total 1539 boxing injuries (from 4313 contests) and 1442 MMA injuries (from 2704 contests) were identified. Boxing had higher eye injury rates compared to MMA ( p < 0.0001), with an odds ratio of 1.268 (95% CI, 1.114-1.444). Eye trauma represented 47.63% of boxing injuries and 25.59% of MMA injuries, with periocular lacerations being the most common eye injury in both. Orbital fractures represented 17.62% of eye injuries in MMA and 3.14% in boxing contests. However, 2%-3% were retinal in both sports, and 3.27% were glaucomatous in boxing. MMA contestants had an odds ratio of 1.823 (95% CI, 1.408-2.359) for requiring physician evaluation following an eye injury compared with boxing. MMA contestants also had a higher rate of face ( p < 0.0001) and body ( p < 0.0001) injuries. For both sports, an increased number of rounds and being the losing fighter were associated with increased odds of eye and face injury.
Although boxing has a higher rate of eye injuries, MMA eye injuries are more likely to require physician evaluation. MMA contestants also have a higher rate of orbital fractures and face and body trauma. A detailed postfight examination and long-term follow-up of ocular injury in combat sports will be vital in proposing reforms to prevent eye trauma.
评估和比较综合格斗(MMA)和拳击的眼外伤和面部外伤。
回顾性队列研究。
从 2000 年至 2020 年,从内华达州运动委员会(NAC)提取拳击和 MMA 比赛的数据。提取比赛、参赛者、结果和伤害的详细信息。
共确定了 1539 例拳击伤(来自 4313 场比赛)和 1442 例 MMA 伤(来自 2704 场比赛)。与 MMA 相比,拳击的眼伤发生率更高(p<0.0001),优势比为 1.268(95%可信区间,1.114-1.444)。眼部外伤占拳击伤的 47.63%,占 MMA 伤的 25.59%,两者中最常见的眼部损伤均为眼周裂伤。眼眶骨折占 MMA 眼部损伤的 17.62%,占拳击比赛的 3.14%。然而,两种运动的视网膜损伤均占 2%-3%,拳击比赛中青光眼损伤占 3.27%。与拳击相比,MMA 参赛者在眼部受伤后需要医生评估的优势比为 1.823(95%可信区间,1.408-2.359)。MMA 参赛者面部(p<0.0001)和身体(p<0.0001)受伤的发生率也更高。对于这两种运动,回合数增加和作为失利拳手与眼外伤和面部外伤的几率增加相关。
尽管拳击的眼部受伤率较高,但 MMA 的眼部受伤更有可能需要医生评估。MMA 参赛者的眼眶骨折以及面部和身体创伤发生率也更高。在综合格斗运动中,对眼部损伤进行详细的赛后检查和长期随访,对于提出改革以防止眼外伤至关重要。