Malchow-Møller A
Ann Med Interne (Paris). 1986;137(3):274-8.
During the recent years a broad spectrum of diagnostic methods have appeared for the differentiation of obstructive and nonobstructive jaundice: ultrasound examination, CT-scan, direct cholangiography, etc. These investigations are costly and not without risks. It is therefore essential to devise an optimal diagnostic strategy for each patient. Extensive clinical and clinical chemical information was collected from 1,002 jaundiced patients. By application of Bayes' theorem and logistic discriminant analysis a diagnostic algorithm was developed based upon 21 variables of the 107 variables collected. This algorithm permitted a probabilistic classification of jaundiced patients into four diagnostic categories: acute non-obstructive, chronic non-obstructive, benign obstructive and malignant obstructive jaundice. Adopting a probability limit of 0.80, 683 patients (69 p. 100) were correctly classified, 34 patients (3.5 p. 100) were wrongly so, and 268 patients (27 p. 100) could not be classified with a probability above 0.80 (doubtful cases). The algorithm was also tested in a further series of 110 jaundiced patients and found to perform equally well: 88 patients classified, 22 patients remaining doubtful. Patients with doubtful diagnoses should be referred to a non-invasive test such as ultrasound examination, whereas patients with definite diagnoses can be referred to invasive tests (liver biopsy, direct cholangiography) as appropriate. The diagnostic algorithm seems to be a reliable tool for the primary differential diagnosis of the jaundiced patient and can be used in the planning of further diagnostic tests for the individual patient.
近年来,出现了多种用于鉴别梗阻性黄疸和非梗阻性黄疸的诊断方法:超声检查、CT扫描、直接胆管造影等。这些检查成本高昂且并非没有风险。因此,为每位患者制定最佳诊断策略至关重要。我们从1002例黄疸患者中收集了广泛的临床和临床化学信息。通过应用贝叶斯定理和逻辑判别分析,基于所收集的107个变量中的21个变量开发了一种诊断算法。该算法能够将黄疸患者概率性地分为四类诊断类别:急性非梗阻性、慢性非梗阻性、良性梗阻性和恶性梗阻性黄疸。采用0.80的概率阈值,683例患者(69%)被正确分类,34例患者(3.5%)被错误分类,268例患者(27%)无法以高于0.80的概率进行分类(可疑病例)。该算法还在另外110例黄疸患者中进行了测试,结果发现表现同样良好:88例患者得到分类,22例患者仍为可疑病例。诊断存疑的患者应接受超声检查等非侵入性检查,而诊断明确的患者可根据情况接受侵入性检查(肝活检、直接胆管造影)。该诊断算法似乎是黄疸患者初步鉴别诊断的可靠工具,可用于为个体患者规划进一步的诊断检查。