Department of Physical Education, College of Education, King Faisal University, Al-Ahsa, Saudi Arabia.
Department of Special Education, College of Education, King Faisal University, Al-Ahsa, Saudi Arabia.
PLoS One. 2023 Sep 8;18(9):e0291274. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0291274. eCollection 2023.
Inclusive educational practices enhance engagement among students with disabilities in school settings. This study aimed to investigate: (i) the general attitudes of non-disabled female Saudi Arabian students toward their peers with disabilities, with a particular focus on the general attitudes towards those with hearing disabilities (HD), intellectual disabilities (ID), and behavioral problems (BP), and (ii) the relationships between three selected student-related characteristics (type of school, in-school contact with peers with disabilities, and out-of-school contact with peers with disabilities).
Using a sample of 678 participants aged 7-12 years old, we tested the impact of personal and contextual factors (age, type of peer disability, type of school, in-school interaction with peers with disabilities, and out-of-school interaction with peers with disabilities on the attitudes of non-disabled Saudi Arabian elementary school students using ANCOVA linear regression analysis.
Regardless of the type of disability, the participants reported having positive attitudes toward peers with disabilities. The type of disability, school, and previous interactions all had a significant effect on fostering positive attitudes toward peers with disabilities, specifically, those with HD, ID, and BP. The participants had less positive attitudes towards their peers with BP compared to their attitudes towards peers students with HD or ID which were more positive and had a larger effect size. The findings also demonstrated that the participants' attitudes toward their peers with HD or ID were influenced by their previous experience of interacting with people with disabilities as well as the type of school they attended. Participants from Saudi ARAMCO (SA) schools had more positive attitudes toward peers with disabilities compared to those from public schools, and participants from non-inclusive schools had more positive attitudes toward peers with disabilities compared to those from inclusive schools. Participants from non-inclusive schools had much more positive attitudes toward peers with disabilities than those from inclusive schools; participants who had previous out-of-school interactions with people with disabilities had significantly more positive attitudes toward peers with disabilities than those who had no previous out-of-school interactions with people with disabilities. Participants from SA schools had the most negative attitudes toward peers with BP, regardless of age.
The findings imply that being taught in an inclusive educational setting in Saudi Arabia does not inevitably encourage non-disabled students to adopt more positive attitudes toward peers with disabilities. Therefore, with the support of their school principals, Saudi Arabian teachers working in inclusive educational settings should be encouraged to develop and implement initiatives to adopt an inclusive strategy based on group projects bringing together students with and without disabilities.
包容性教育实践增强了残疾学生在学校环境中的参与度。本研究旨在调查:(i)非残疾沙特阿拉伯女学生对残疾同伴的普遍态度,特别关注对听力残疾(HD)、智力残疾(ID)和行为问题(BP)的一般态度,以及(ii)三个选定的学生相关特征(学校类型、与残疾同伴在校内的接触以及与残疾同伴在校外的接触)之间的关系。
使用 678 名 7-12 岁参与者的样本,我们使用协方差线性回归分析测试了个人和环境因素(年龄、同伴残疾类型、学校类型、与残疾同伴在校内的互动以及与残疾同伴在校外的互动)对非残疾沙特阿拉伯小学生态度的影响。
无论残疾类型如何,参与者都对残疾同伴表现出积极的态度。残疾类型、学校和以前的互动都对培养对残疾同伴的积极态度有显著影响,特别是对 HD、ID 和 BP 残疾的同伴。与对 HD 或 ID 残疾同伴的态度相比,参与者对 BP 残疾同伴的态度不那么积极,而且态度的影响更大。研究结果还表明,参与者对 HD 或 ID 残疾同伴的态度受到他们以前与残疾人士互动的经历以及他们所就读学校的类型的影响。来自沙特阿美(SA)学校的参与者对残疾同伴的态度比来自公立学校的参与者更为积极,而来自非包容性学校的参与者对残疾同伴的态度比来自包容性学校的参与者更为积极。来自非包容性学校的参与者对残疾同伴的态度比来自包容性学校的参与者更为积极;与以前没有与残疾人士进行过校外互动的参与者相比,以前有过校外与残疾人士互动的参与者对残疾同伴的态度更为积极。来自 SA 学校的参与者对 BP 残疾同伴的态度最为消极,无论年龄大小。
这些发现表明,在沙特阿拉伯接受包容性教育并不一定会鼓励非残疾学生对残疾同伴采取更积极的态度。因此,在学校校长的支持下,在包容性教育环境中工作的沙特阿拉伯教师应被鼓励制定和实施基于小组项目的包容性策略,将残疾和非残疾学生聚集在一起。