Babaoğlu Ali Samet
Department of Food Engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, Selçuk University, Konya 42100, Türkiye.
Food Sci Anim Resour. 2023 Sep;43(5):826-839. doi: 10.5851/kosfa.2023.e38. Epub 2023 Sep 1.
This study investigated the effects of different charcoals on the occurrence of 16 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in grilled beef steaks and beef patties. Seven different charcoals were used as follows: from oak wood (C1), from orange wood (C2), from Valonia oak wood (C3), from Marabu wood (C4), extruded charcoal from beech wood (C5), from coconut shells (C6), and from hazelnut shells (C7). The grilling times for each charcoal type were 6 min for the beef patties and 7 min for the beef steaks, until the internal temperature reached at least 74°C. The total concentration of 16 PAHs (PAH16) in beef steaks grilled with C1 (35.75 μg/kg) and C7 (36.39 μg/kg) was higher than that of C3 (23.80 μg/kg) and C6 (24.48 μg/kg; p<0.05). The highest amounts of PAH16 (216.40 μg/kg) were determined in the beef patty samples grilled using C5 (p<0.05). The summation of benzo[a]anthracene, chrysene, benzo[b]fluoranthene and benzo[a]pyrene, referred to as PAH4, was not detected in any of the beef steaks, whereas it was determined in the beef patties grilled with C2 (7.72 μg/kg) and C5 (22.95 μg/kg; p<0.05). The PAH16 concentrations of the beef patty samples in each charcoal group were significantly higher compared to the beef steaks (p<0.05). To avoid the formation of high PAH levels, the use of extruded charcoal and hazelnut shell charcoal should therefore be avoided when charcoal grilling beef steaks and beef patties, and low-fat meat products should be preferred.
本研究调查了不同木炭对烤牛排和牛肉饼中16种多环芳烃(PAHs)生成情况的影响。使用了七种不同的木炭,具体如下:橡木木炭(C1)、橙木炭(C2)、瓦洛尼亚橡木木炭(C3)、马拉布木炭(C4)、山毛榉木挤压木炭(C5)、椰壳木炭(C6)和榛子壳木炭(C7)。每种木炭类型用于烤制牛肉饼的时间为6分钟,烤制牛排的时间为7分钟,直到内部温度至少达到74°C。用C1(35.75μg/kg)和C7(36.39μg/kg)烤制的牛排中16种多环芳烃(PAH16)的总浓度高于用C3(23.80μg/kg)和C6(24.48μg/kg;p<0.05)烤制的牛排。在用C5烤制的牛肉饼样品中测定出最高含量的PAH16(216.40μg/kg;p<0.05)。在任何牛排中均未检测到苯并[a]蒽、屈、苯并[b]荧蒽和苯并[a]芘的总和,即PAH4,而在用C2(7.72μg/kg)和C5(22.95μg/kg;p<0.05)烤制的牛肉饼中检测到了PAH4。每个木炭组中牛肉饼样品的PAH16浓度均显著高于牛排(p<0.05)。因此,为避免形成高含量的多环芳烃,在用木炭烤制牛排和牛肉饼时应避免使用挤压木炭和榛子壳木炭,并且应优先选择低脂肉类产品。