Albert George P, McHugh Daryl C, Hwang David Y, Creutzfeldt Claire J, Holloway Robert G, George Benjamin P
Department of Neurology, University of Rochester Medical Center, NY (G.P.A., D.C.M., R.G.H., B.P.G.).
Department of Neurology, University of North Carolina School of Medicine, Chapel Hill (D.Y.H.).
Stroke. 2023 Oct;54(10):2602-2612. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.123.043176. Epub 2023 Sep 14.
Patients with stroke receiving invasive mechanical ventilation (IMV) and tracheostomy incur intense treatment and long hospitalizations. We aimed to evaluate US hospitalization costs for patients with stroke requiring IMV, tracheostomy, or no ventilation.
We performed a retrospective observational study of US hospitalizations for acute ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage, and subarachnoid hemorrhage receiving IMV, tracheostomy, or none using the National Inpatient Sample, 2008 to 2017. We calculated hospitalization costs using cost-to-charge ratios adjusted to 2017 US dollars for inpatients with stroke by ventilation status (no IMV, IMV alone, tracheostomy).
Of an estimated 5.2 million (95% CI, 5.1-5.3) acute stroke hospitalizations, 2008 to 2017; 9.4% received IMV alone and 1.4% received tracheostomy. Length of stay for patients without IMV was shorter (median, 4 days; interquartile range [IQR], 2-6) compared with IMV alone (median, 6 days; [IQR, 2-13]), and tracheostomy (median, 25 days; [IQR, 18-36]; <0.001). Mortality for patients without IMV was 3.2% compared with 51.2% for IMV alone and 9.8% for tracheostomy (<0.001). Median hospitalization costs for patients without IMV was $9503 (IQR, $6544-$14 963), compared with $23 774 (IQR, $10 900-$47 735) for IMV alone and $95 380 (IQR, $63 921-$144 019) for tracheostomy. Tracheostomy placement in ≤7 days had lower costs compared with placement in >7 days (median, $71 470 [IQR, $47 863-$108 250] versus $102 979 [IQR, $69 563-$152 543]; <0.001). Each day awaiting tracheostomy was associated with a 2.9% cost increase (95% CI, 2.6%-3.1%). US hospitalization costs for patients with acute stroke were $8.7 billion/y (95% CI, $8.5-$8.9 billion). For IMV alone, costs were $1.8 billion/y (95% CI, $1.7-$1.9 billion) and for tracheostomy $824 million/y (95% CI, $789.7-$858.3 million).
Patients with acute stroke who undergo tracheostomy account for 1.4% of stroke admissions and 9.5% of US stroke hospitalization costs. Future research should focus on the added value to society and patients of IMV and tracheostomy, in particular after 7 days for the latter procedure given the increased costs incurred and poor outcomes in stroke.
接受有创机械通气(IMV)和气管切开术的中风患者需要 intensive 治疗且住院时间长。我们旨在评估需要 IMV、气管切开术或无需通气的中风患者在美国的住院费用。
我们使用 2008 年至 2017 年的全国住院患者样本,对因急性缺血性中风、脑出血和蛛网膜下腔出血接受 IMV、气管切开术或未接受通气的美国住院患者进行了回顾性观察研究。我们根据中风患者的通气状态(未接受 IMV、仅接受 IMV、气管切开术),使用调整为 2017 年美元的成本收费比来计算住院费用。
在 2008 年至 2017 年估计的 520 万例急性中风住院病例中,9.4%仅接受 IMV,1.4%接受气管切开术。未接受 IMV 的患者住院时间较短(中位数为 4 天;四分位间距[IQR]为 2 - 6),而仅接受 IMV 的患者住院时间中位数为 6 天([IQR,2 - 13]),接受气管切开术的患者住院时间中位数为 25 天([IQR,18 - 36];<0.001)。未接受 IMV 的患者死亡率为 3.2%,而仅接受 IMV 的患者死亡率为 51.2%,接受气管切开术的患者死亡率为 9.8%(<0.001)。未接受 IMV 的患者住院费用中位数为 9503 美元(IQR,6544 - 14963 美元),而仅接受 IMV 的患者为 23774 美元(IQR,10900 - 47735 美元),接受气管切开术的患者为 95380 美元(IQR,63921 - 144019 美元)。气管切开术在≤7 天内进行的成本低于在>7 天内进行(中位数,71470 美元[IQR,47863 - 108250 美元]对 102979 美元[IQR,69563 - 152543 美元];<0.001)。等待气管切开术的每一天与成本增加 2.9%相关(95%CI,2.6% - 3.1%)。美国急性中风患者的住院费用为每年 87 亿美元(95%CI,85 - 89 亿美元)。仅对于 IMV,费用为每年 18 亿美元(95%CI,17 - 19 亿美元),对于气管切开术为每年 8.24 亿美元(95%CI,7.897 - 8.583 亿美元)。
接受气管切开术的急性中风患者占中风入院病例的 1.4%,占美国中风住院费用的 9.5%。未来的研究应关注 IMV 和气管切开术对社会和患者的附加价值,特别是对于后者,考虑到中风患者后期成本增加和预后不良,尤其要关注术后 7 天以后的情况。