Zhang Z, Wang L, Zhao Y H, Jiang T, Zhang Z Z, Wang X, Hu L F, Xiao M H
Department of Bariatric and Metabolic Surgery, China-Japan Union Hospital, Jilin University, Changchun 130033, China.
Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2023 Sep 25;26(9):859-865. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn441530-20221025-00431.
To evaluate the 1-year postoperative efficacy of four bariatric procedures, namely sleeve gastrectomy (SG), Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB), single anastomosis duodenal-ileal bypass with sleeve gastrectomy (SADI-S), and biliopancreatic diversion with duodenal switch (BPD/DS) for treating super obesity. In this retrospective observational study, we analyzed the clinical data of 40 patients with super obesity (body mass index [BMI]≥50 kg/m) who had undergone bariatric surgery in the China-Japan Union Hospital of Jilin University from November 2015 to December 2020. The study cohort consisted of 21 men and 19 women of average age 31.7±9.0 years. The preoperative weight and BMI were (159.2±16.9) kg and (53.4±3.0) kg/m, respectively. Prior to the surgery, 30 individuals had hypertension, 27 hyperuricemia, 15 type 2 diabetes, 10 abnormally high total cholesterol, 20 abnormally high triglycerides, and 24 abnormally high low-density lipoprotein. We divided the participants into four groups according to the type of operation: SG group (=16), RYGB group (=9), SADI-S group (=9) and BPD/DS group (=6). We examined the following factors: weight, BMI, excess weight loss (%), total weight loss (%), and remission of preoperative metabolic diseases (including hypertension, hyperuricemia, type 2 diabetes, and hyperlipidemia) 3, 6, and 12 months after surgery. The variables assessed for hypertension were systolic and diastolic blood pressure; for type 2 diabetes, glycated hemoglobin; and for hyperlipidemia, total cholesterol, triglycerides, and low-density lipoprotein 1-year after the surgery. The safety of surgery was also assessed. All patients successfully completed laparoscopic procedures, none of them requiring conversion to laparotomy. The amount of blood loss during surgery was less than 50 mL. Postoperative hospital stay was 6-16 days. There were no deaths during the perioperative period. However, two postoperative complications occurred in the RYGB group, namely bleeding and anastomotic leakage. No complications were detected in the other groups. At 3, 6, and 12 months after surgery, percentage of excess weight loss was 36.6±11.0, 62.4±15.7, and 68.2±16.0 (=21.830, <0.001) in the SG group; 30.6±6.9, 42.5±5.8, and 50.6±11.1 (=13.222, <0.001) in the RYGB group; 39.7±7.8, 54.6±12.7, and 81.9±12.0 (=33.821, <0.001) in the SADI-S group; and 40.2±4.8, 57.7±11.8, and 82.8±14.9 (=21.552, <0.001), respectively, in the BPD/DS group. The percentage of excess weight loss increased significantly over the 12-month observation period in all groups . Compared with before surgery, hypertension and hyperuricemia in the SG, SADI-S, and BPD-DS groups showed significant improvement after one year (all <0.05). However, only the SADI-S group exhibited a significant decrease in glycosylated hemoglobin concentrations (=0.038). Only the BPD-DS group showed significant decreases in various indicators of hyperlipidemia (all <0.05). The improvements in obesity-related complication indexes did not reach statistical significance in the RYGB group (all >0.05). SG, RYGB, SADI-S and BPD/DS are all safe and effective treatments for super obesity. All of these procedures can improve the associated metabolic diseases to a certain extent.
评估四种减肥手术,即袖状胃切除术(SG)、Roux-en-Y胃旁路术(RYGB)、单吻合口十二指肠-回肠旁路术联合袖状胃切除术(SADI-S)和胆胰分流十二指肠转位术(BPD/DS)治疗超级肥胖症的术后1年疗效。在这项回顾性观察研究中,我们分析了2015年11月至2020年12月在吉林大学中日联谊医院接受减肥手术的40例超级肥胖患者(体重指数[BMI]≥50 kg/m²)的临床资料。研究队列包括21名男性和19名女性,平均年龄31.7±9.0岁。术前体重和BMI分别为(159.2±16.9)kg和(53.4±3.0)kg/m²。手术前,30人患有高血压,27人患有高尿酸血症,15人患有2型糖尿病,10人总胆固醇异常高,20人甘油三酯异常高,24人低密度脂蛋白异常高。我们根据手术类型将参与者分为四组:SG组(n = 16)、RYGB组(n = 9)、SADI-S组(n = 9)和BPD/DS组(n = 6)。我们检查了以下因素:术后3、6和12个月的体重、BMI、超重减轻百分比(%)、总体重减轻百分比(%)以及术前代谢疾病(包括高血压、高尿酸血症、2型糖尿病和高脂血症)的缓解情况。评估高血压的变量为收缩压和舒张压;评估2型糖尿病的变量为糖化血红蛋白;评估高脂血症的变量为术后1年的总胆固醇、甘油三酯和低密度脂蛋白。还评估了手术的安全性。所有患者均成功完成腹腔镜手术程序,无一例需要转为开腹手术。手术期间失血量少于50 mL。术后住院时间为6 - 16天。围手术期无死亡病例。然而,RYGB组发生了2例术后并发症,即出血和吻合口漏。其他组未检测到并发症。术后3、6和12个月,SG组的超重减轻百分比分别为36.6±11.0、62.4±15.7和68.2±16.0(F = 21.830,P < 0.001);RYGB组分别为30.6±6.9、42.5±5.8和50.6±11.1(F = 13.222,P < 0.001);SADI-S组分别为39.7±7.8、54.6±12.7和81.9±12.0(F = 33.821,P < 0.001);BPD/DS组分别为40.2±4.8、57.7±11.8和82.8±14.9(F = 21.552,P < 0.001)。在所有组中,超重减轻百分比在12个月的观察期内均显著增加。与手术前相比,SG组、SADI-S组和BPD - DS组的高血压和高尿酸血症在1年后有显著改善(均P < 0.05)。然而,只有SADI-S组的糖化血红蛋白浓度显著降低(P = 0.038)。只有BPD - DS组的高脂血症各项指标显著降低(均P < 0.05)。RYGB组肥胖相关并发症指标的改善未达到统计学意义(均P > 0.05)。SG、RYGB、SADI-S和BPD/DS都是治疗超级肥胖症的安全有效的方法。所有这些手术都能在一定程度上改善相关的代谢疾病。