Iwo René, Ruiz-Casares Mónica, Nazif-Muñoz José Ignacio
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC USA.
McGill University, Montreal, Quebec Canada.
Child Indic Res. 2023;16(5):2013-2032. doi: 10.1007/s12187-023-10038-w. Epub 2023 May 27.
Research from industrialized settings has linked inadequate child supervision with various negative consequences. Nevertheless, empirical research in lower- and middle-income countries about correlates of inadequate child supervision has been scarce. The few studies that exist tended to focus on individual- and household-level factors, and reported associations that are not significant or in mixed directions depending on the context. Structural factors are left underexplored, but taking a more macro-level lens in settings with high regional disparities can hold the key to explaining increases in prevalence of inadequate child supervision. Exploring the evolution over time of child supervision practices can also enrich this explanation. We use data from two rounds of Ghana Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys to examine factors associated with children left home alone, and employ regional analysis using strata-level mixed effects. We found that in Ghana, the prevalence of children left home alone without adult supervision increased by 8.5% between 2011 and 2018 - an increase of more than 500,000 children over seven years. Statistical analyses suggest that variation between regions likely are associated with the growth of inadequate child supervision in this country. Future research should pay closer attention to how structural conditions, proxied by regions, can serve as either barriers or facilitators to adequate child supervision practices, helping shed light on residual variance unexplained by individual- and household-level factors.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12187-023-10038-w.
工业化环境下的研究已将儿童监管不足与各种负面后果联系起来。然而,低收入和中等收入国家关于儿童监管不足相关因素的实证研究却很匮乏。现有的少数研究往往侧重于个人和家庭层面的因素,并且所报告的关联并不显著,或者根据具体情况呈现出不同的方向。结构因素尚未得到充分探索,但在区域差异较大的环境中从更宏观的层面进行审视,可能是解释儿童监管不足患病率上升的关键。探究儿童监管做法随时间的演变也可以丰富这一解释。我们使用两轮加纳多指标类集调查的数据来研究与儿童独自在家相关的因素,并采用分层混合效应进行区域分析。我们发现,在加纳,2011年至2018年间,无人监管独自在家的儿童患病率上升了8.5%——七年内增加了超过50万名儿童。统计分析表明,各地区之间的差异可能与该国儿童监管不足情况的增加有关。未来的研究应更加关注以地区为代表的结构条件如何既可能成为儿童适当监管做法的障碍,也可能成为促进因素,这有助于揭示个人和家庭层面因素无法解释的剩余差异。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s12187-023-10038-w获取的补充材料。